1 3
Exp Brain Res
DOI 10.1007/s00221-015-4394-6
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Is there a link between sensorimotor coordination
and inter-manual coordination? Differential effects of auditory
and/or visual rhythmic stimulations
Mélody Blais
1
· Jean-Michel Albaret
1
· Jessica Tallet
1
Received: 4 February 2015 / Accepted: 22 July 2015
© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2015
suggest that there is dissociation between processes underly-
ing sensorimotor synchronization (anticipation or reactivity)
and processes underlying inter-manual coordination (motor
control). This finding opens new perspectives to evaluate
separately the possible sensorimotor and inter-manual coor-
dination deficits present in movement disorders.
Keywords Tapping · Synchronization · Anticipation ·
Reaction · Inphase/antiphase patterns · Beat/metronome ·
Perceptual-motor coupling · Audio-visual integration
Introduction
In 1958, Fraisse emphasized the tight coupling between
motor behavior and rhythmic sensory stimuli in human
(Fraisse et al. 1958). Everyday situations such as walking,
clapping, dancing or playing music highlight the strong
tendency of motor behavior to synchronize with environ-
mental rhythms in adults (Fraisse 1948; Fraisse et al. 1958;
Repp et al. 2011) and children (Getchell 2006). According
to Repp (2005), sensorimotor synchronization (SMS) refers
to temporal coordination between rhythmic movement and
regular environmental stimuli (i.e., repetitive isochronous
pattern of sensory stimuli). In experiments, SMS is investi-
gated using unimanual finger tapping tasks, requiring partic-
ipants to synchronize finger taps with auditory or/and visual
metronomes in a given period of time (see Repp 2005). Syn-
chrony/asynchrony can be assessed by computing the mean
time delay between each stimulus and its corresponding tap
and the variability of the mean delay over time (Chen et al.
2002). Studies on SMS reveal that mean asynchrony is gen-
erally negative in adults who are not musicians. Negative
SMS suggests that participants tend to tap before the onset
of the stimuli (Fraisse 1948; Repp 2005).
Abstract The purpose of this study was to test how the
sensory modality of rhythmic stimuli affects the production
of bimanual coordination patterns. To this aim, participants
had to synchronize the taps of their two index fingers with
auditory and visual stimuli presented separately (auditory or
visual) or simultaneously (audio-visual). This kind of task
requires two levels of coordination: (1) sensorimotor coor-
dination, which can be measured by the mean asynchrony
between the beat of the stimulus and the corresponding tap
and by mean asynchrony stability, and (2) inter-manual coor-
dination, which can be assessed by the accuracy and stabil-
ity of the relative phase between the right-hand and left-hand
taps. Previous studies show that sensorimotor coordination
is better during the synchronization with auditory or audio-
visual metronomes than with visual metronome, but it is
not known whether inter-manual coordination is affected by
stimulation modalities. To answer this question, 13 partici-
pants were required to tap their index fingers in synchrony
with the beat of auditory and/or visual stimuli specify-
ing three coordination patterns: two preferred inphase and
antiphase patterns and a non-preferred intermediate pattern.
A first main result demonstrated that inphase tapping had the
best inter-manual stability, but the worst asynchrony stabil-
ity. The second main finding revealed that for all patterns,
audio-visual stimulation improved the stability of sensori-
motor coordination but not of inter-manual coordination.
The combination of visual and auditory modalities results
in multisensory integration, which improves sensorimotor
coordination but not inter-manual coordination. Both results
* Jessica Tallet
jessica.tallet@univ-tlse3.fr
1
Laboratory PRISSMH-LAPMA (EA 4651), University
of Paul Sabatier Toulouse 3, 31062 Toulouse, France