Transactions of the ASABE
Vol. 57(6): 1687-1696 © 2014 American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers ISSN 2151-0032 DOI 10.13031/trans.57.10202 1687
TECHNICAL NOTE:
APPLICABILITY OF KRIGING FOR ESTIMATING
GROUNDWATER FLOW AND NUTRIENT LOADS
SURROUNDING PINEVIEW RESERVOIR, UTAH
T. N. Reuben, D. L. Sorensen
ABSTRACT. The total maximum daily load (TMDL) study for Pineview Reservoir in Ogden Valley, Utah, called for reduc-
tions in phosphorus loads from irrigated agriculture and on-site wastewater treatment systems, but historical groundwater
flow estimates and associated phosphorus loads were highly variable and based on little data. The objective of the present
study was to quantify the spatial variability of groundwater flow, groundwater nutrient concentrations, and nutrient
transport toward Pineview Reservoir and improve the groundwater flow and nutrient loading estimates for the reservoir
using this information. ArcGIS kriging techniques were employed in analyzing high-frequency groundwater flow and
grab-sample nutrient concentration data. Results from the study showed large spatial variations in groundwater flows and
nutrient loadings. Spatial variation in flows was attributed to variations in hydraulic gradients and saturated thickness,
while nutrient loading variations were attributed to source variations and nutrient flushing to groundwater due to snow-
melt and irrigation water. Both agricultural and domestic nonpoint sources appeared to influence the nutrient loadings.
The median total dissolved phosphorus concentration (32 μg P L
-1
) for five of the nine wells monitored was more than
three-fold lower than the median (104 μg P L
-1
) for all nine wells, signifying large spatial variations. Spatial variation in
flow rate had confidence intervals ranging from 1,518 to 5,077 m
3
d
-1
on 6 May 2011 to 447 to 1,814 m
3
d
-1
on 27 June
2011. Knowledge of the spatial distribution of nutrient concentrations and loading would help decision makers in deter-
mining specific management practices that would help abate groundwater nutrient loading and its subsequent impact on
surface water bodies.
Keywords. GIS, Groundwater, Kriging, Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Spatial variability.
utrophication of reservoirs in the U.S. inter-
mountain west is usually attributed to increasing
phosphorus concentrations in the water column,
which results in cyanobacteria and algae growth to
unacceptable concentrations (Hein, 2006). Pineview Reser-
voir’s TMDL study (USEPA, 2011) stipulated the need to
reduce both nitrogen and phosphorus loadings by 15% in
order to abate eutrophication (Utah DEQ, 2002). The reser-
voir is located in Ogden Valley, approximately 11 km east of
Ogden City in Weber County, Utah. It is an impoundment of
the Ogden River and receives water from the North, Middle,
and South Forks of the Ogden River, Geertsen Creek, Spring
Creek, various other smaller tributaries, and groundwater.
Pineview Reservoir’s maximum storage capacity is approx-
imately 140 × 10
6
m
3
(WBWQMC, 1990; Winkelaar, 2010).
Groundwater flow and subsequent nutrient loading esti-
mates to Pineview Reservoir have been made before
(Avery, 1994; Miner et al., 1990; Reuben et al., 2011; Utah
DEQ, 2002). The Clean Lakes Study estimated that the
annual groundwater contribution from the water table aqui-
fer to Pineview Reservoir was approximately 25 × 10
6
m
3
(Miner et al., 1990). Miner et al. (1990) estimated the
groundwater flows based on data from five monitoring
wells studied during the 1988 irrigation season, but the
method used to calculate the groundwater flow was not
described. Avery (1994) simulated groundwater flows in
Ogden Valley and estimated that the annual groundwater
contribution from the water table aquifer to Pineview Res-
ervoir was approximately 33 × 10
6
m
3
. Avery (1994) en-
countered problems with sparse data, especially for the
water table aquifer, and therefore recommended further
studies involving more monitoring wells over a longer
monitoring period. A study conducted for the Utah De-
partment of Environmental Quality (Utah DEQ, 2002) used
the flow estimated by the Clean Lakes Study to estimate N
and P loading to the reservoir. The researchers also recom-
mended that more studies be conducted to fill data gaps.
Reuben et al. (2011) determined surface and groundwa-
ter flow rates and nutrient (nitrogen, phosphorus, iron, and
dissolved organic carbon) loadings as well as the fate of
phosphorus in Pineview Reservoir. They reported that an
inflow of 3.4 × 10
6
m
3
year
-1
from the water table aquifer,
approximately 2% of the total annual reservoir inflow, car-
ried 22% of the NO
3
+ NO
2
-N (nitrate-N) and 2.6% of the
dissolved phosphorus annual loads to Pineview Reservoir.
Submitted for review in April 2013 as manuscript number SW 10202;
approved as a Technical Note for publication by the Soil & Water
Division of ASABE in October 2014.
The authors are Thomas N. Reuben, ASABE Member, Postdoctoral
Associate, and Darwin L. Sorensen, Research Professor, Utah Water
Research Laboratory, Utah State University, Logan, Utah. Corresponding
author: Darwin Sorensen, 8200 Old Main Hill, Utah State University,
Logan, UT 84322-8200; phone: 435-797-3207; e-mail: darwin. sorensen
@usu.edu
E