1 Copyright © 2015 by Rolls-Royce plc
Proceedings of the 14
th
International Symposium on Unsteady Aerodynamics,
Aeroacoustics & Aeroelasticity of Turbomachines
ISUAAAT14
8-11 September 2015, Stockholm, Sweden
I14-S12-1
ON LIP STALL SUPPRESSION IN POWERED INTAKE: HIGH AND LOW FIDELITY
APPROACH
Mauro Carnevale
Department of Mechanical Engineering
Imperial college of London, SW7 2BX, UK
m.carnevale@imperial.ac.uk
Jeff S. Green
Rolls-Royce plc
Derby, DE24 8BJ,UK
Luca di Mare
Department of Mechanical Engineering
Imperial college of London, SW7 2BX, UK
ABSTRACT
This work describes a computational and analytical study
of the flow in a turbofan intake at high incidence. It is well
known that lip separation can occur above a certain angle
of flight incidence, depending on the flight Mach number,
Reynolds number and engine mass flow rate. There has
been a steady rise in the lower lip loading in turbofan
installations in recent years. This trend is set to continue
because of the necessity to reduce the installation weight
and drag in view of the introduction of ultra-high bypass
ratio engines. This makes designs with shorter and thinner
lips more attractive, but at the same time riskier because of
the occurrence of lip separation.
Once separation occurs, a distortion with pressure, entropy
and vortical components is passed into the fan. While these
distortions are potentially detrimental to the life and
stability of the fan, it is also known that the presence of the
fan itself changes the conditions at which separation
occurs. It is important therefore, to investigate and
understand the mechanism by which the fan modifies the
flow in the intake.
In this study, detailed simulations have been performed of
powered and aspirated intakes at the same reduced mass
flow rate and spanning a wide range of incidence angles.
Geometries representative of real engine configuration
have been used. The computational results are shown to be
in agreement with wind tunnel results and demonstrate the
beneficial effect of the fan on the intake flow.
Furthermore, the distortions at fan face are analysed using
wave decomposition.
It is shown that the effect of the fan is carried by the
rejected waves generated at fan face - consistently with
actuator disc theory - but it is amplified by the nature of
the separated flow in the intake.
INTRODUCTION
It is a commonly accepted design practice to provide
the Low Pressure Compression system (LPC) with uniform
flow under all operating conditions. Under this point of
view the intake represents the most critical component.
High distortion levels to fan stage and therefore to the
OGV and ESS blades, can cause blades instability and
have detrimental effects on whole compression system.
At the same time, the presence of the LPC modifies the
flow in the intake. A beneficial effect of the presence of the
fan has been demonstrated in term of improving the stall
margin of fan stage.
In recent years Computational Fluid Dynamic CFD
provides a robust and high fidelity approach to investigate
the interaction mechanisms in intake-fan coupled systems.
The weak point of these kind of approaches lies on the
high computational costs and make them not suitable for
preliminary design process. Fast tools are therefore
necessary to investigate the distortion propagation for early
stage of the design process or whenever a quick solution is
desirable, when minimal assumptions are made about the
studied geometry and nature of the gas.
A large literature review based on low fidelity methods
and their application to problem (typically acoustic)
involving distortions in boundary conditions is available.
Satyanaryan et al [1] compared theoretical results and
experimental data highlight the necessity to overcome the
single blade analysis models. In 1969, Kaji & Okazaki [2]
have described a model, providing the magnitudes of the
reflected and transmitted waves as they approach the blade
cascade. This approach represents the widest validation