Gender-speciic constructions of the ‘other
religion’ in French and Austrian discourse on
Turkey’s accession to the European Union*
Karin Bischof, Florian Oberhuber and Karin Stögner
Institute of Conlict Research, Vienna
his article presents results from a qualitative analysis of religious and gender-
speciic ‘othering’ in Austrian and French media discourse on Turkey’s accession
to the EU (2004–2006). A typology of arguments justifying inclusion and exclu-
sion of Turkey from Europe or the EU is presented, and gender-speciic other-
ing is placed in the context of difering national discourses about Europe and
diverging visions of secularisation and citizenship. Secondly, various topoi of
orientalism are reconstructed which play a crucial role in both national corpora,
and it is shown how various historically shaped discourses of alterity intersect
and produce gendered images of cultural and religious otherness.
Keywords: European Union, enlargement, Turkey, discourse analysis, print
media, identity, orientalism, France, Austria
1. Introduction
In Europe, cleavages and conlicts are increasingly interpreted in terms of religious
values and religious ailiation, and especially Islam is constructed as the ‘other
religion’ (cf. Göle 2002, Fetzer and Soper 2005). Contested issues and policy ac-
tion included the building of mosques in European town centres, forced marriage
or the wearing of headscarves in public institutions. Hence, gender in particular
seems to be a central terrain of cultural and social alterity constructions.
his article is based on the results of a research project on current conigura-
tions of European identity and religiously interpreted cleavages in the EU.
1
he
new paradigms of alterity at the intersection of gender and religion were ana-
lysed as a key resource for better understanding the European and national self
and the challenges that religious diversity implies for national and European
Journal of Language and Politics 9:3 (2010), 364–392. doi 10.1075/jlp.9.3.02bis
issn 1569–2159 / e-issn 1569–9862 © John Benjamins Publishing Company