Violence makes safe in South African prisons
Prison gangs, violent acts, and victimization among inmates
Marie Rosenkrantz Lindegaard and Sasha Gear
Abstract: That gangs have a prominent place in South African prison violence—
like in many other geographical contexts—has become increasingly clear. Based
on qualitative research among South African inmates and ex-inmates, we propose
that prison gangs be considered adaptation strategies to the extremely coercive
and oppressive environments of prisons. We focus on the relationship between
gang involvement in prison, violent acts among inmates, and the risk of being sub-
jected to violence during incarceration. By providing emic perspectives, we aim to
demonstrate how inmates negotiate three types of social roles, largely defined by
their ability and willingness to use violence: franse, gangster, and wyfie. Our find-
ings suggest that prison gangs may jeopardize the personal safety of inmates, but
can also paradoxically offer some inmates the opportunity to establish a sense of
safety and agency by avoiding random violence.
Keywords: adaptation strategies, inmate culture, prison gangs, prison violence,
safety, sexual violence
Violent acts among inmates have largely been
associated with prison gangs. Prison gangs have
been found to be a key source of violent crimi-
nal acts and other acts of noncompliance inside
prisons in the United States (Drury and DeLisi
2011). For example, Fischer (2001) noted that
prison gang members were two to three times
more likely than nongang inmates to commit
serious disciplinary violations. Using two sam-
ples of youths paroled from California Youth
Authority institutions in the United States,
MacDonald (1999) found that gang members
were 30 percent more likely to commit assorted
acts of prison violence. Gaes et al. (2002) like-
wise showed that among sentenced male in-
mates in the custody of the Federal Bureau of
Prisons in United States, gang affiliation, inde-
pendent of other variables, increased the likeli-
hood of inmate misconduct. In a study of mis-
conduct in 298 medium- and maximum-security
facilities in the United States, Reisig (2002) re-
ported that facilities with a higher percentage of
gang members experienced significantly higher
rates of inmate homicides. Misconduct in
prison has been explained as the consequence
of high concentrations of lower-educated young
men with a criminal history (Berg and DeLisi
2006); as the result of the pains experienced by
Focaal—Journal of Global and Historical Anthropology 68 (2014): 35–54
© Stichting Focaal and Berghahn Books
doi:10.3167/fcl.2014.680103