Lisa M Garland Baird, Tess Miller
Lisa M Garland Baird, Clinical Nursing Instructor, School of Nursing,Tess Miller, Associate Professor, Faculty of Education,
University of Prince Edward Island, Prince Edward Island, Canada
Email: lmgarland@upei.ca
Factors influencing
evidence-based practice
for community nurses
ABSTRACT
Factors influencing the development of evidence-based nursing practice
(EBNP) were examined in Prince Edward Island, Canada. An adapted
electronic questionnaire was distributed to practicing registered nurses and
nurse practitioners (n=68). An analysis of variance revealed a significant
difference between nurses’ clinical practice setting and the EBNP scale.
Significant differences were also found between age and education level
when compared with the EBNP subscales where novice nurses were less
likely to rely on experience and intuition, and expert nurses with a higher
level of education reported being more skilful at synthesising and applying
information from research findings into their nursing practice.
KEY WORDS
Evidence-based nursing Community health nursing
Clinical practice setting Age Education
a literal application of knowledge and procedures that call
for direct supervision, to being able to independently and
competently perform skills at a professional level with
efficiency (Miller and Dawson, 2014). In addition, novice
nurses are commencing their careers in health-care envi-
ronments where policies and procedures require rapid
internalisation. Incorporating EBNP for this age group
has been a challenging experience, since novice nurses
experienced more barriers to implementing change and
were less confident in the application of EBNP (Gerrish
et al, 2007).
With respect to levels of education, it was recognised
that continued education for nurses positively affects
practice. However, the dearth of available empirical evi-
dence supporting this claim challenges the assumption
that increased levels of nursing education directly affect
patient care and health outcomes (Cotterill-Walker,
2012). Organisational culture has also been found to play
a significant role in whether nurses apply research to
their practice. Furthermore, perceptions of organisational
support were shown to be the most important facilitator
T
he Canadian Nurses Association (CNA) broadly
define evidence-based nursing practice (EBNP) as
a continuous interactive process involving explicit,
conscientious, and judicious consideration of the best avail-
able evidence to provide care (CNA, 2010). EBNP assists
nurses in making informed and evidence-based clinical
decisions; increases engagement in professional develop-
ment and feelings of autonomy; promotes consistency and
efficiency of safe, quality care; and contributes to improved
client health outcomes and a reduction in health-care
system costs. EBNP is conceptualised into five domains
(Gerrish et al, 2007):
Sources of knowledge used in professional practice
Barriers to finding and reviewing nursing research
and practice evidence
Barriers to changing nursing practice
Facilitators to changing nursing practice
Skills in finding, reviewing, and using
evidence sources.
This conceptualisation of nursing practice applies to
individual registered nurses (RNs) and nurse practition-
ers (NPs), and extends to nursing practice in health-care
organisations and clinical settings that include public
health, home care, and primary care. Further, EBNP is
a pivotal concept in addressing the needs of the larger
Canadian health-care system in general.
The five domains (i.e. dependent variables) that affect
nurses’ (RNs and NPs) engagement with EBNP have
been influenced by their age, level of education, position
of responsibility within an organisation, and perceptions
of organisational support (Milner et al, 2006; Eizenberg,
2011). In focusing on the age domain, nursing practice
has become more challenging for ageing nurses owing
to the frequent updates in technologies and the need to
incorporate research evidence into practice (CNA, 2010).
At the other end of the age spectrum, novice nurses are
faced with cognitive and skill demands as they transform
from a nursing student to a practicing nurse. This trans-
formation involves moving from skill sets dependent on
British Journal of Community Nursing May 2015 Vol 20, No 5 233
RESEARCH
© 2015 MA Healthcare Ltd