Abstract—Mobile phone handsets such as those operating in
the GSM network emit extremely low frequency
electromagnetic fields ranging from DC to at least 40 kHz. As a
subpart of an extended protocol, the influence of these fields on
the human resting EEG has been investigated in a fully counter
balanced, double blind, cross-over design study that recruited
72 healthy volunteers. A decrease in the alpha frequency band
was observed during the 20 minutes of ELF exposure in the
exposed hemisphere only. This result suggests that ELF fields
as emitted from GSM handsets during the DTX mode may
have an effect on the resting alpha band of the human EEG.
I. INTRODUCTION
HERE is ongoing concern regarding possible health and
biological effects that can arise from the exposure of
users to the electromagnetic emissions that personal
telecommunication devices such as Global System for
Mobiles (GSM) handsets emit. Investigations seem to detect
biological effects associated with the exposure in equal
frequency with investigations that do not. This fact
combined with the absence of any acceptable physical
mechanism that could explain any of the observed effects
requires empirical tests of the possibility to continue.
We have previously examined the effects of continuous
and pulsed mobile phone like radiation on the human resting
EEG [1], and so have many others [2]. One aspect of mobile
phone exposure, which remains sidelined in current research
in comparison to RF, is that caused by the Extremely Low
Frequency (ELF) field which is produced by the flow of
currents inside handset devices. The sole influence of this
exposure on human brain variables has yet to be studied.
Some relevant works are those that used real handsets for
their investigations, and as such combine RF and ELF
exposures. Examples are the works of Russel and Cosic [3],
Curcio et al. [4], and Croft et al. [5], but are difficult to
compare due to the combination of exposures. The works of
Cook et al. are also relevant where changes in brain activity
Manuscript received April 7, 2008.
N. Perentos is with RMIT University, Melbourne, VIC 3000, Australia
(phone: +61 4 2192 5572; fax: +61 3 9925 2954; e-mail: n.perentos@
student.rmit.edu.au).
R. Croft is with Swinburne University, Melbourne, Australia (e-mail:
RCroft@groupwise.swin.edu.au).
R. McKenzie is with RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia (e-mail:
Ray.McKenzie@rmit.edu.au).
D. Cvetkovic is with RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia (e-mail:
Dean.Cvetkovic@rmit.edu.au).
I. Cosic is with RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia (e-mail:
Irena.Cosic@rmit.edu.au).
after and during exposure to pulsed ELF fields were
observed [6, 7]. However, field characteristics in the works
of Cook et al. significantly differed from those of mobile
phones. Differences lie in the intensity, frequency content
and spatial distribution of the fields.
These characteristics have been studied by a few
independent laboratories. The radiation is found to be
spatially confined in close proximity to the source and
spatial field decay is rapid, dropping significantly by the
time it reaches the centre of the brain [8, 9]. The radiation
dose associated with these ELF exposures has also been
assessed and was found to be well below relevant exposure
guidelines.
So while technical and dosimetric aspects of the fields
have been the subject of investigations it remains to
determine whether they are capable of causing any
measurable changes in brain variables.
The statistical variation and contradictory nature of
previous results in RF bioeffects literature can be avoided by
employing robust experimental protocols. A similar
approach was followed in our earlier study where we
adjusted the experimental protocol accordingly, partly
building on previous research, to avoid most methodological
limitations. However one such limitation remained, that of
small sample size, which led us to view those results with
caution.
In fact very few studies have used sample sizes greater
than 30 and just two studies have recruited more than 50
volunteers [5, 10]. The significance of large samples is also
stressed in a recent review by Valentini et al. [2].
To address this issue and the relative lack of large sample
size studies we performed an extended double blind study
where we recruited 72 healthy participants and studied their
resting brain activity under three different electromagnetic
radiations, pulse modulated RF, continuous RF and ELF
fields. In this paper we present results pertaining to the ELF
exposure, and specifically the resting brain activity in the
alpha band region.
II. MATERIALS AND METHODS
A. Subjects
Seventy two healthy volunteers (35 female and 37 male)
participated in the study. The mean age of the sample was
24.5 years and the standard deviation was 5.4 years.
Participants were instructed to abstain from alcohol
The effect of GSM-like ELF radiation on the alpha band of the
human resting EEG
Nicholas Perentos, Rodney J. Croft, Raymond J. McKenzie, Dean Cvetkovic, and Irena Cosic, Senior
Member, IEEE
T
30th Annual International IEEE EMBS Conference
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada, August 20-24, 2008
978-1-4244-1815-2/08/$25.00 ©2008 IEEE. 5680
Authorized licensed use limited to: RMIT University. Downloaded on March 30,2010 at 18:53:23 EDT from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.