Treatment fidelity as a predictor of behaviour
change in parents attending group-based
parent training
C. Eames, D. Daley, J. Hutchings, C. J. Whitaker, K. Jones, J. C. Hughes and T. Bywater
School of Psychology, College of Health and Behavioural Sciences, Bangor University, Gwynedd, UK
Accepted for publication 8 February 2009
Keywords
behaviour, fidelity,
parenting, preschool
children, treatment
Correspondence:
Catrin Eames BSc, School
of Psychology, College of
Health and Behavioural
Sciences, Bangor
University, Gwynedd LL57
2AS, UK
E-mail:
c.eames@bangor.ac.uk
Abstract
Background Change in parenting skills, particularly increased positive parenting, has been
identified as the key component of successful evidence-based parent training (PT), playing a causal
role in subsequent child behaviour change for both prevention and treatment of Conduct Disorder.
The amount of change in parenting skills observed after PT varies and may be accounted for by
both the content of the programme and by the level of PT implementer process skills. Such
variation in implementer skills is an important component in the assessment of treatment fidelity,
itself an essential factor in successful intervention outcome.
Aims To establish whether the Leader Observation Tool, a reliable and valid process skills fidelity
measure, can predict change in parenting skills after attendance on the Incredible Years PT
programme.
Results Positive leader skills categories of the Leader Observation Tool significantly predicted
change in both parent-reported and independently observed parenting skills behaviour, which in
turn, predicted change in child behaviour outcome.
Conclusions Delivering an intervention with a high level of treatment fidelity not only preserves
the behaviour change mechanisms of the intervention, but can also predict parental behaviour
change, which itself predicts child behaviour change as a result of treatment.
Introduction
Conduct Disorder in the early years
One in 10 of 5- to 16-year-olds in the UK has a mental health
disorder meeting clinical criteria, with Conduct Disorder (CD)
the most prevalent of these, accounting for 60% of children
with mental health disorders (Office for National Statistics
2004). Disruptive behaviour problems among children aged
five and over are the most common reason for mental health
service referral in both the UK and the USA (Belsky et al.
2006). Externalizing behaviour patterns such as aggression
towards peers, non-compliance and poor impulse regulation
can be identified in early childhood and are precursors
to clinically significant behaviour problems that become
evident during school age and which, without intervention,
can remain stable from toddler-hood throughout childhood,
adolescence and adulthood (Richman et al. 1982; Campbell
1995; Pierce et al. 1999). Despite formal diagnosis predomi-
nantly occurring between middle childhood and middle ado-
lescence, it may also occur in the preschool years [American
Psychiatric Association (APA) 2000], sometimes as early as
2 years of age (Shaw et al. 2000; Wakschlag and colleagues
2005).
Child:
care, health and development
Original Article doi:10.1111/j.1365-2214.2009.00975.x
© 2009 The Authors
Journal compilation © 2009 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 603