Democratic Consequences
of Hostile Media Perceptions
The Case of Gaza Settlers
Yariv Tsfati and Jonathan Cohen
In this article,the authors examine the consequences of the hostile-media phenome-
non and advance the argument that people’s perceptions of hostile coverage shape
their trust in mainstream media institutions.Media trust in turn affectstrust in democ-
racy and willingness to accept democratic decisions. T hese ideas are tested on a sam-
ple of Jewish Settlers in the G aza Strip,in the weeks before a Likud Par ty vote on Israeli
Prime Minister Ariel Sharon’s plan to pull out of the Gaza Strip and evacuate settlers
from their homes. Findings show that hostile media perceptions were negatively
related to settlers’ trust in media and that trust in media waspositively related to trust
in democracy, which, in turn, affected settlers’ intentions to forcefully resist Sharon’s
evacuation plan. N o direct association was found between hostile media perceptions
and intentions to forcefully resist evacuation.
Keywords: hostile media perceptions;trust in media;trust in democracy; Gaza settler
Democracy serves as a mechanism for solving disputes between opposing ideol-
ogies and groups through debate and discourse. This mechanism encourages
people to obey laws they disagree with and that go against their individual inter-
ests in the name of majority rule and of the collective good. In this sense, democ-
racy replaces the use of force as a coordinating principle, allowing the conduct of
social life. News media are central to this process, both as forums for exchanging
views—outlets for attempting to persuade a majority of the people—and tools
for disseminating information necessary for collective deliberation. Though
people are often critical of news coverage and are aware that the information
provided by the media is not always perfect, the media remain an important
social institution for democratic deliberation.
28
Press/ Politics 10(4):28-51
DOI: 10.1177/ 1081180X05280776
© 2005 by the President and the Fellows of Harvard College