Rapid Waste Composition Studies for the Assessment of Solid Waste
Management Systems in Developing Countries
Max J Krause and Timothy G Townsend
*
Environmental Engineering Sciences, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL 32611, USA
*
Corresponding author: Timothy G Townsend, Environmental Engineering Sciences, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL 32611, USA, Tel: (352) 392-0846; Fax: (352)
392-3394; E-mail: ttown@ufl.edu
Received date: March 28, 2014; Accepted date: May 05, 2014; Published date: May 12, 2014
Copyright: ©2014 Townsend TG, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Abstract
A methodology for the rapid assessment of waste composition was assessed by examining municipal solid waste
from five rural communities throughout Central America and the Caribbean. Target waste components were
minimized and a sieve-shaker table was employed to maximize the quantity of waste that could be sorted in an
efficient and timely manner. Food waste (along with other fine materials) was the largest component by weight, but
plastics represented a major fraction. To illustrate potential utility of composition study results, the data were used to
estimate the methane generation potential, L
0
, of each municipality’s waste stream. While the approach does not
provide the statistical rigor of more standardized waste composition methodologies, the technique does provide a
tool for rapid assessment of local waste characteristics.
Keywords: Waste composition; Food waste; Landfill; Central
America; Haiti; Methane potential
Introduction
Adequate solid waste management systems (SWMS) have lagged in
developing countries behind other infrastructure needs. Rural
municipalities, in particular, do not have the resources to construct
and maintain the infrastructure that supports the use of conventional
waste collection vehicles. While rural municipalities are often legally
responsible for municipal solid waste (MSW) collection for all
residents, the burden often falls to informal businesses. Without
formal contracts or established liabilities, collectors often dispose of
the waste wherever they can [1,2]. In many cases, an unmanaged
dump site is established over several years or decades. While this
creates a single, isolated source of pollution, it also concentrates the
liquid and gaseous emissions. Furthermore, as technology advances
and social habits change, waste composition changes. Whereas most of
the waste dumped twenty years ago in rural areas may have been
predominantly organic and biodegradable, the proliferation of plastics,
electronics, and other environmentally persistent materials within
current waste streams warrant modern SWMS.
To address the problems posed from sub-standard waste disposal,
rural communities are often urged to implement more sustainable
SWMS, both by national regulations and by outside parties. Challenges
to implementing more sustainable practices include limited financial
resources and the need to match an appropriate technology to the
region’s specific waste characteristics. Accurate waste composition
data can be a crucial tool for selecting an appropriate waste
management approach; the relative fractions of food waste, plastics,
metals, and other components dictate the viability of technologies such
as composting, anaerobic digestion, thermal energy recovery, and
recycling. Such data are often lacking in developing countries [3–6],
and even rarer in rural areas [7,8]. The cost and nature of the studies
can be prohibitive to small and local governments, as they are typically
performed over a period of multiple days or weeks, and sampling
events are repeated throughout the year [9–11]. The largest direct cost
of a composition study is attributed to labor, which typically requires 4
to 12 operators as well as a supervisor [9,12].
The work presented in this paper was motivated by challenges the
authors faced as part of several efforts providing assistance to rural
communities on waste management issues. Some estimate of the
composition of the local waste stream was desired, but time and
resources were not available for a complete waste composition study.
Over several trips, a protocol was developed that allowed a quick
evaluation of a municipality’s waste stream in a single sampling event.
A description and assessment of this procedure are presented within to
provide benefit to others interested in similar activities. Results of
composition studies from Costa Rica, Guatemala, Haiti, and Honduras
are described, and the utility of the results are illustrated by estimating
the MSW methane potential, L
0
(m
3
CH
4
/Mg MSW) of the different
communities and through evaluating the occurrence of plastics in each
waste stream. Other challenges with respect to waste collection and
management in the subject communities are also discussed to provide
a broader context of issues to the reader.
Materials and Methods
Site Descriptions
Rapid waste composition studies were performed on six waste
streams in five rural towns across Central America from 2010 to 2013
as part of an on-going effort by the authors to assess current waste
management practices in developing countries and assist local
communities. As illustrated in Figure 1, the locations included Nosara,
Costa Rica; Tactic and San Juan Chamelco, Guatemala; Cabaret, Haiti;
and Villa de San Francisco, Honduras. The waste streams examined in
the study were market or residential waste as indicated in Table 1. The
local markets were the primary sources of commerce within the
communities. As such, large amounts of waste were generated weekly
at these central locations.
International Journal of Waste
Resources
Krause MJ and Townsend TG, Int J Waste
Resources 2014, 4:2
http://dx.doi.org/10.4172/2252-5211.1000145
Research Article Open Access
Int J Waste Resources
ISSN:2252-5211 IJWR, an open access journal
Volume 4 • Issue 2 • 1000145