ARTICLES
PUBLISHED ONLINE: 9 JANUARY 2011 | DOI: 10.1038/NMAT2934
Disorder-induced localization in crystalline
phase-change materials
T. Siegrist
1,2
, P. Jost
1
, H. Volker
1
, M. Woda
1
, P. Merkelbach
1
, C. Schlockermann
1
and M. Wuttig
1,3
*
Localization of charge carriers in crystalline solids has been the subject of numerous investigations over more than half a
century. Materials that show a metal–insulator transition without a structural change are therefore of interest. Mechanisms
leading to metal–insulator transition include electron correlation (Mott transition) or disorder (Anderson localization), but a
clear distinction is difficult. Here we report on a metal–insulator transition on increasing annealing temperature for a group of
crystalline phase-change materials, where the metal–insulator transition is due to strong disorder usually associated only with
amorphous solids. With pronounced disorder but weak electron correlation, these phase-change materials form an unparalleled
quantum state of matter. Their universal electronic behaviour seems to be at the origin of the remarkable reproducibility of the
resistance switching that is crucial to their applications in non-volatile-memory devices. Controlling the degree of disorder in
crystalline phase-change materials might enable multilevel resistance states in upcoming storage devices.
F
ew properties have provided such a wealth of information
on solids as that of charge-carrier transport. The electrical
resistivity is highly valuable to characterize solids, because the
room-temperature resistivity for different materials spans more
than 32 orders of magnitude
1
. Two different types of solid can
be distinguished on the basis of the temperature dependencies of
their resistivity: experimentally the temperature coefficient of the
resistivity (TCR) is used to separate metallic (dρ/dT > 0) from
insulating behaviour (dρ/dT < 0). Theoretical studies instead focus
on the low-temperature limit of the resistivity, or the reciprocal
quantity (electrical conductivity). The conductivity of insulators
vanishes as T goes to 0 K; metals reveal a finite conductivity. This
immediately raises the question of a minimum conductivity for
metals. Indeed, Mott
2
argued that no metallic state at 0 K is possible
below a minimum conductivity
3
. Experimental investigations of
doped semiconductors, however, show a metallic-state conductivity
that is lower by at least three orders of magnitude
4
, in line with
scaling theory
5
.
Although many models of a metal–insulator transition (MIT)
invoke a change of the crystal structure on the transition
6
, two well-
known concepts exist where the transition occurs without a change
in crystallographic phase. According to Mott, an MIT arises if the
electron interaction energy (correlation) exceeds the Fermi energy
7
.
A second route has been identified by Anderson, who showed that
increasing disorder turns the delocalized electronic states at the
Fermi energy into localized states
8
, with a quasiclassical version oc-
curring in heavily doped and highly compensated semiconductors
9
.
A rich playground to study electronically driven MITs was
identified in phosphorus-doped silicon (Si:P; refs 4,10,11), with the
MIT occurring on reaching a critical concentration of free carriers
with doping. An MIT predicted by Mott is expected because the
increasing carrier concentration reduces the electron-correlation-
to-Fermi-energy ratio. However, doping also introduces disorder
because dopant atoms statistically occupy sites of the silicon
lattice. Hence this MIT has also been discussed as a manifestation
of an Anderson transition
12–14
. As aspects of both a Mott
1
I. Physikalisches Institut (IA), RWTH Aachen University, 52056 Aachen, Germany,
2
Department of Chemical and Biomedical Engineering, Florida State
University, Tallahassee, Florida 32310, USA,
3
JARA-FIT, RWTH Aachen University, I. Physikalisches Institut (IA), 52056 Aachen, Germany.
*e-mail: wuttig@physik.rwth-aachen.de.
(correlation) and an Anderson (disorder) transition are prevalent,
the MIT in doped semiconductors is now considered to have both
signatures
12–14
. Until now, no three-dimensional crystalline solid is
known where the MIT can solely be attributed to a varying degree
of disorder (Anderson localization).
Here, we present electronic-transport measurements for several
phase-change materials (PCMs) in the crystalline state, which reveal
unusual transport properties. PCMs that reversibly switch between
an amorphous and a crystalline state show a pronounced change of
optical and electrical properties. They may contain chalcogens, in
particular Te, or pnicogens such as Sb, for example GeTe, GeSb
2
Te
4
,
Ge
2
Sb
2
Te
5
and doped Sb or Sb
2
Te. The resistivity can be used for
data storage owing to a large drop on crystallization, often exceeding
four orders of magnitude
15
. As the amorphous-to-crystalline-state
transformation proceeds at moderately elevated temperatures on a
nanosecond timescale
16–18
, PCMs have attracted strong interest for
optical and electronic data storage
19
.
Resistivity measurements of two as-deposited amorphous thin
films of GeTe and GeSb
2
Te
4
are depicted in Fig. 1. Starting at room
temperature, the films are heated at a constant rate of 5 K min
−1
;
the resistivity smoothly decreases because the amorphous phase is
semiconducting. With the onset of crystallization, the resistivity
suddenly drops by several orders of magnitude. Interestingly, in
one material (GeTe), the resistivity in the crystalline state does not
depend on the annealing temperature and the resistivity change
proceeds within a narrow temperature window in one single
step. It is generally accepted that crystalline GeTe is a degenerate
semiconductor (see for instance
20
), that is, the Fermi energy lies
within the valence band (details in Supplementary Information),
resulting in metal-like behaviour and thus a metallic TCR. In
GeSb
2
Te
4
, crystallization is also accompanied by a steep decrease
in resistivity. In contrast to GeTe, however, the resistivity in
the crystalline state of GeSb
2
Te
4
shows a pronounced annealing
dependence. We note that for GeSb
2
Te
4
the TCR changes from
non-metallic (TCR < 0) to metallic (TCR > 0) behaviour on
annealing and the corresponding transition is drawn out over a
202 NATURE MATERIALS | VOL 10 | MARCH 2011 | www.nature.com/naturematerials
© 2011 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved