Can. J. Earth Sci. 44: 367–387 (2007) doi:10.1139/E07-003 © 2007 NRC Canada
367
Spindle-shaped Ediacara fossils from the
Mistaken Point assemblage, Avalon Zone,
Newfoundland
James G. Gehling and Guy M. Narbonne
Abstract: The Mistaken Point assemblage of the Ediacara fossils is dominated by rangeomorphs with homologous
fractal branching elements. The most distinctive are the fusiform fossils, herein named Fractofusus misrai n.gen., and
n.sp., and Fractofusus andersoni n.gen., and n.sp. Although endemic to the Newfoundland portion of the Avalonia
terrane, they dominated deep sea-floor communities below the photic zone, in the mid-Ediacaran Period (ca. 575–
560 Ma). Their biological affinities remain uncertain, but their architecture suggests a phylogenetic position near the
base of the Metazoa.
Résumé : L’assemblage de fossiles édiacariens de Mistaken Point est dominé par des rangeomorphes présentant des
éléments homologues à embranchement fractal. Les plus distinctifs sont des fossiles fusiformes ici nommés Fractofu-
sus misrai n.gen. et n.sp. et Fractofusus andersoni n.gen. et n.sp. Bien qu’ils soient endémiques à la portion terre-
neuvienne du terrane d’Avalon, ils dominaient de communautés du fond marin profond sous la zone photique durant la
période édiacarienne moyenne (v. 575–560 Ma). Leurs affinités biologiques demeurent incertaines, mais leur architec-
ture laisse croire à une position phylogénétique près de la base des Métazoaires.
[Traduit par la Rédaction] Gehling and Narbonne 387
Introduction
Fossils of the Ediacara biota, best known from the
Flinders Ranges in South Australia (Sprigg 1947; 1949),
characterize the recently defined Ediacaran Period, the first
Precambrian time division to be ratified with a Global
Stratotype Section and Point (Knoll et al. 2006). Ediacara-
type fossils occur mainly as centimetre- to metre-scale im-
pressions of soft-bodied animals preserved underneath event
beds of sandstone or volcanic ash (Narbonne 2005; Gehling
et al. 2005). Some Ediacara-type fossils may represent stem
groups of modern animal phyla (Gehling 1987, 1988;
Conway Morris 1993; Gehling and Rigby 1996; Fedonkin
and Waggoner 1997; Lin et al. 2006), whereas others appear
to represent failed experiments in the early evolution of
multicellular life (Seilacher 1992; Buss and Seilacher 1994;
Narbonne 2004). The best-known example of the latter group
are the rangeomorphs, an extinct high-order taxon character-
ized by centimetre-scale fractally branching modules in
decimetre- to metre-scale frondose, comb-like, or bush-like
structures (Jenkins 1985; Narbonne 2004, 2005). The most
distinctive, and by far the most common, rangeomorphs in
the Mistaken Point assemblage are fossils colloquially
known as “spindle-shaped fossils.” These were the first
Ediacaran fossils ever discovered or figured from Mistaken
Point (Anderson and Misra 1968) and spindles have been
figured in virtually every subsequent paper on the Mistaken
Point assemblage. Spindle-shaped fossils are endemic to the
Avalon Zone of eastern Newfoundland, and large bedding
surfaces throughout the Avalon and the northern Bonavista
peninsulas (Fig. 1) are crowded with hundreds to thousands
of specimens.
The realization that Ediacara fossils occur well below
strata bearing undoubted early Cambrian fossils, established
their priority in the record of megascopic life on Earth. The
discovery of the Charnwood Forest assemblage of the
Ediacara biota in Leicester, England by Roger Mason (Ford
1958) confirmed the likely Precambrian position of these
enigmatic fossils (Glaessner and Daily 1959) and stimulated
a new phase of global research into the origins of animal life
on Earth. Glaessner and Daily (1959) recognized that
frondose fossils previously described by Gürich (1933) from
southwestern Africa (Namibia) were of equivalent age. The
discovery, a decade later, of the Mistaken Point assemblage
(Anderson and Misra 1968; Misra 1969) in the Conception
Group of southeastern Newfoundland greatly expanded the
diversity of forms in the Ediacara biota. In the last 40 years,
fossils of the Ediacara biota have been discovered on all
continents except Antarctica.
Received 20 December 2006. Accepted 23 January 2007.
Published on the NRC Research Press Web site at
http://cjes.nrc.ca on 21 May 2007.
Paper handled by Associate Editor J. Jin.
J.G. Gehling.
1,2
Department of Geological Sciences, Queen’s
University, Kingston, ON K7L 3N6 Canada and Department
of Earth Sciences, Monash University, Clayton, VIC, 3168
Australia.
G.M. Narbonne. Department of Geological Sciences and
Geological Engineering, Queen’s University, Kingston, ON
K7L 3N6, Canada; and Royal Ontario Museum, 100 Queen’s
Park, Toronto, ON M5S 2C6, Canada.
1
Present address: South Australian Museum, North Terrace,
Adelaide, SA, 5000 Australia.
2
Corresponding author (e-mail: gehling.jim@saugov.sa.gov.au).