Abstract – This paper presents a methodology to design
interoperable lean, agile, resilient, and green industrial
ecosystems based on axiomatic design. The main objective is
to develop a systematic approach to support the detailed
design of collaborative business platforms that are able to
deliver high level of interoperability, as measured by the
expanded business interoperability quotient measurement
model. To achieve this objective, axiomatic design is
employed to develop the “ideal” cooperation configuration
by defining and aligning a set of functional requirements
necessary to establish an effective and efficient cooperation
among networked organizations. The applicability of the
developed methodology is tested through an application
scenario of implementing reverse logistics among an
automaker focal firm and its upstream partners, as well as
some external stakeholders.
Keywords – business interoperability, industrial
ecosystems, LARG, axiomatic design, reverse logistics
I. INTRODUCTION
Collaborative industrial ecosystems (IE) continuously
face the need for finding and establishing new
cooperation arrangements in order to maximize the
efficiency of existing resources. IEs are complex and
involve a number of actors, each one with its
organizational structure, business goals, management
approach, business processes, culture and work methods
and information systems (IS). Therefore, there is a need to
align these different issues when high levels of
interoperability are required, as for example when
networked organizations are aiming at implementing lean,
agile, resilient and green (LARG) management practices
that interconnect across the various participants in IE.
This implies the arrangement of a set of interoperability
factors among the involved actors. In this context, we
propose an axiomatic-based methodology to describe how
networked organizations can establish cooperation
mechanisms to implement interoperable management
practices. Interoperable management practices are defined
as those that require the interaction of two or more
organizations in their implementation. This paper presents
an application scenario related to reverse logistics (RL)
The paper is organized as follows: Section two
reviews the key topics of this research, namely business
interoperability, collaborative LARG industrial
ecosystems, axiomatic design (AD) and RL. Section three
presents a proposal for the design of an interoperable RL
network. Section four provides a brief discussion about
the strengths and weaknesses of the presented
methodology. At last, conclusions and paths for future
work are presented.
II. LITERATURE REVIEW: KEY TOPICS
A. Business interoperability
Business interoperability is considered as the
organizational and operational ability of an enterprise to
cooperate with its business partners and to efficiently
establish, conduct and develop information technology
(IT)-supported business with the objective of creating
value [1]. In this context, interoperability and business
interoperability frameworks proposed by ATHENA [2, 3],
the European interoperability framework (EIF) [4],
ECOLEAD [5], levels of information systems
interoperability (LISI) [6], levels of conceptual
interoperability framework (LCIF) [7], interoperability
developments for enterprise application and software
(IDEAS) [8] and business interoperability quotient
measurement model (BIQMM) [9], contributed to this
area giving clues of what are the aspects of business
cooperation that must be achieved to obtain the “optimal
interoperability”. The role of these frameworks in the
current work is to provide the main guidelines to
decompose business activities into the business
interoperability parameters (BIP) perspective.
B. LARG industrial ecosystems
Collaborative networks or IEs are a collection of
heterogeneous organizations with different competences,
but symbiotic interests that join and efficiently combine
the most suitable set of skills and resources (knowledge,
capital, assets, etc.) for a period of time in order to
achieve a common objective, and make use of
information and communication technologies (ICTs) to
coordinate, develop and support their activities” [10]. The
term LARG is used to describe the combination of lean,
agile, resilient, and green paradigms. The focus of lean
paradigm has essentially been on the cost minimization
and waste elimination [11] for increasing added value, in
order to fulfill customer’s needs while maintaining profits
[12]. Unlike lean, the focus of agile paradigm is the
ability of comprehension and rapid response to market
changes, in terms of volume and variety [11, 12].
Resilience is related to both the individual and
organizational responses to turbulence and discontinuities
[13]. The green paradigm is concerned with the reduction
A Methodology for Designing an Interoperable Industrial Ecosystems, using the
Axiomatic Design Theory
I. Cabral
1
, P. Espadinha-Cruz
1
, A. Grilo
1
, A. Gonçalves-Coelho
1
, A. Mourão
1
1
UNIDEMI, Departamento de Engenharia Mecânica e Industrial, Faculdade de Ciências e Tecnologi a, Universidade Nova
de Lisboa, Caparica, Portugal
(corresponding author: i.cabral@campus.fct.unl.pt)
978-1-4799-0986-5/13/$31.00 ©2013 IEEE