SPINE Volume 35, Number 17, pp 1589 –1594
©2010, Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
Effects of Vision and Tactile Stimulation of the Neck on
Postural Control During Unperturbed Stance and Cervical
Joint Position Sense in Young Asymptomatic Adults
Nicolas Pinsault, PhD, PT,*† Benjamin Bouvier, PT,† Yannick Sarrazin, PT,†
and Nicolas Vuillerme, PhD*‡
Study Design. Before and after intervention trials.
Objective. To evaluate the effects of visual input and
tactile stimulation of the neck on postural control during
unperturbed stance and cervical joint position sense.
Summary of Background Data. Although beneficial ef-
fects on lower-limb joints proprioception have been reported
when vision was available and when tactile stimulation was
applied around lower-limb joints, there has hitherto been no
study investigating whether and how vision and tactile stim-
ulation applied to the neck could modify postural control
during unperturbed stance and joint position sense.
Methods. The effects of visual input and tactile stimu-
lation of the neck on postural control during unperturbed
stance (Experiments 1 and 2) and cervical joint position
sense (Experiments 3 and 4) were assessed in four sepa-
rate experiments. During these experiments, two experi-
mental tasks (a postural task during unperturbed stance
and the CRT to NHP) were executed without (No vision)
and with the availability of the vision (Vision) and without
(No tactile stimulation condition) and with the application
of strips of adhesive bandage to the skin over and around
the neck (Tactile stimulation condition). Twelve different
subjects participated in the four experiments.
Results. For experiments 1 and 2, decreased centre of
foot pressure displacements were observed in the Vision
relative to the No vision and in the Tactile stimulation
relative to the No tactile stimulation condition. For exper-
iments 3 and 4, more accurate and more consistent repo-
sitioning performances were observed in the Vision rela-
tive to the No vision and in the Tactile stimulation relative
to the No tactile stimulation condition, as indicated by
decreased absolute and variable errors, respectively.
Conclusion. Altogether, our results suggest that sub-
jects were able to take advantage of vision and increased
neck cutaneous information provided by the by strips of
adhesive bandage applied to the neck to improve postural
control during unperturbed stance and cervical joint posi-
tion sense.
Key words: neck, cutaneous, vision, proprioception,
balance. Spine 2010;35:1589 –1594
It is now well recognized that vision
1
and neck somato-
sensation
2
play a major role in the control of human
upright posture. Indeed, previous studies have reported
an improvement of postural control when visual inputs
are available and reliable.
3
In contrast, other previous
studies have reported an alteration of postural control
when the reliance of cervical proprioceptive information
was impaired by pathology, trauma, or injury,
4–6
or in
healthy subjects by experimental manipulations, such as
neck muscles vibration,
7,8
neck muscles fatigue,
9,10
or
neck pain.
11
Although physiologists generally agree that
muscle and joint afferents are the main contributors to
proprioception,
12,13
numerous studies have used brace
or bandage, directly applied on the skin around joint, as
tools for assessing the contribution of cutaneous infor-
mation on proprioception and postural control during
unperturbed stance in young healthy adults. Interest-
ingly, although beneficial effects have been reported on
lower-limb joints proprioception when vision was avail-
able
14
and when tactile stimulation was applied,
15–18
there has hitherto been no study investigating whether
and how tactile stimulation applied to the neck could
modify postural control during unperturbed stance and
cervical joint position sense, and whether and how the
availability of visual information could modify cervical
joint position sense in asymptomatic individuals.
The objective of this study was thus to evaluate the
effects of visual input and tactile stimulation of the neck
on postural control during unperturbed stance and cer-
vical joint position sense in young asymptomatic adults.
It was hypothesized that both vision and tactile stimula-
tion of the neck would improve postural control during
unperturbed stance (hypothesis 1) and cervical joint po-
sition sense (hypothesis 2).
Materials and Methods
Subjects
Twelve young asymptomatic male university students (Table 1)
participated in the 4 separate experiments of the present study.
Criteria for selection and inclusion were male gender,
aged 20 to 30 years. Exclusion criteria were sagittal and/or
coronal alignment of the neck impairment, history of motor
problem, neck pain, neurologic disease, or vestibular impair-
ment. All subjects were examined by an ophthalmologist and
From the *AFIRM and AGIM3 Teams, TIMC-IMAG Laboratory,
UMR UJF CNRS 5525, La Tronche, France; †Ecole de Kine ´sithe ´rapie,
CHU Grenoble, France; and ‡CIC-IT 805, INSERM/AP-HP, Raymond
Poincare Hospital, EA 4497, Garches, France.
Acknowledgment date: March 24, 2008. Revision date: June 10, 2009.
Acceptance date: July 13, 2009.
The manuscript submitted does not contain information about medical
device(s)/drug(s).
Ministere de l’ Enseignement National et de la Recherche Tech-
nologique francais funds were received in support of this work. No
benefits in any form have been or will be received from a commercial
party related directly or indirectly to the subject of this manuscript.
Supported by the Ministe `re de l’Enseignement National et de la Re-
cherche Technologique franc ¸ais (21528 –2006).
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Nicolas Vuillerme,
PhD, AFIRM and AGIM3 Teams, TIMC-IMAG Laboratory, UMR
UJF CNRS 5525, Faculty of Medicine, 38706 La Tronche cedex,
France; E-mail: nicolas.vuillerme@imag.fr
1589