Fluid Phase Equilibria 394 (2015) 175–185
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Fluid Phase Equilibria
jou rn al h om epage: www.elsevier.com/locate/fluid
Barotropic phenomena in binary mixtures
Héctor Quinteros-Lama
a,∗
, Gerardo Pisoni
b
, José Matías Garrido
a
, Andrés Mejía
a
,
Hugo Segura
a
a
Department of Chemical Engineering, Universidad de Concepción, Concepción 4070386, Chile
b
Facultad de ciencias exactas físicas y matemáticas, Universidad Nacional de Córdoba, Córdoba X5016GCA, Argentina
a r t i c l e i n f o
Article history:
Received 7 January 2015
Received in revised form 27 February 2015
Accepted 3 March 2015
Available online 12 March 2015
Keywords:
Barotropy
Isopycnicity
Mass density inversion
Equations of State (EoS)
Global phase diagram (GPD)
a b s t r a c t
This contribution aims to theoretically describe the most common cases of mass and molar density inver-
sions, as they can be observed in multi-component fluid mixtures in sub-critical phase equilibrium. These
phenomena – also known as barotropy – affect the relative position of phases in a gravitational field for
the case of mass barotropy, while the total population of species along the interfacial length is drasti-
cally affected for the case of molar barotropy. Rigorous and analytical relationships are developed here
to detect both mass and molar density inversions ending at the critical points of mixtures. These condi-
tions, which are useful to describe the existence and persistence of density inversions, are then applied
to unequivocally demonstrate that mass and molar barotropy are physically independent phenomena.
Qualitative evidence pointing to that conclusion is discussed at the light of the global phase diagram of
van der Waals mixtures composed by molecules of different size. Particularly, it has been established that
molar density inversions appearing in feasible temperature ranges are sensitive to differences between
the molecular hard core volumes of the constituents, a conclusion that is well supported by experimen-
tal results. Mass density inversions, in contrast, depend not only on the molecular size but also in the
molecular weights of the constituents, in such a way that mixtures may exhibit mass barotropy without
exhibiting molar inversions, and vice versa.
Analytical relationships for establishing the slope of density inversions on a P–T projection have also
been obtained both for mass and molar barotropy. From the comparison with the temperature slope of the
three-phase line, we conclude about the possibility of observing density inversions between immiscible
liquid phases or between a liquid and a gas phase.
© 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Barotropy – also known as density or volume inversions –
corresponds to a singular condition of phase equilibrium where it
is observed that the densities of – at least – two phases coexisting
in a heterogeneous mixture invert [1–3]. Isopycnicity, in turn,
corresponds to the condition where a barotropic point or a density
inversion exactly occurs [3]. In general, density inversions may be
primarily classified in terms of mass or molar barotropy depending
on the units in which volumes become equivalent at the specific
isopycnic conditions. Particularly, from a mechanical viewpoint,
mass barotropy is a phenomenon that affects the relative position
of the involved phases in a gravitational field, while it has been
reported that the total population of species (or total density
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +56 412981359.
E-mail address: hquinteros@me.com (H. Quinteros-Lama).
profiles) is affected along the interfacial length for the case of
molar barotropy [4].
In a recent publication, Tardón et al. [4] developed a set of
rigorous mathematical conditions for detecting ranges of molar
isopycnicity. As it was established in that paper, in addition to
the necessary conditions of phase equilibrium, a heterogeneous
mixture exhibiting molar isopycnicity between its ˛-ˇ phases is
characterized by an inversion of molar volumes, ˜ v (or molar densi-
ties ),
˜ v
˛
= ˜ v
ˇ
⇔
˛
=
ˇ
(1)
From their results systematically applied to mixtures in the
vicinity of the critical point, Tardón et al. [4] were able to demon-
strate that a stable critical molar density inversion point (CMoDIP)
of a binary mixture satisfies the following relationships,
˜
A
2x
=
˜
A
3x
=
˜
A
xv
= 0 (2)
Here,
˜
A corresponds to the Helmholtz energy function of
the mixture while
˜
A
mxnv
is a shorthand notation for the partial
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.fluid.2015.03.004
0378-3812/© 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.