The Effects of Growth Hormone on Body Composition and Physical
Performance in Recreational Athletes
A Randomized Trial
Udo Meinhardt, MD; Anne E. Nelson, PhD; Jennifer L. Hansen, RN; Vita Birzniece, MD, PhD; David Clifford, PhD; Kin-Chuen Leung, PhD;
Kenneth Graham, BSc; and Ken K.Y. Ho, MD
Background: Growth hormone is widely abused by athletes, fre-
quently with androgenic steroids. Its effects on performance are
unclear.
Objective: To determine the effect of growth hormone alone
or with testosterone on body composition and measures of
performance.
Design: Randomized, placebo-controlled, blinded study of 8 weeks
of treatment followed by a 6-week washout period. Randomization
was computer-generated with concealed allocation. (Australian–
New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry registration number:
ACTRN012605000508673)
Setting: Clinical research facility in Sydney, Australia.
Participants: 96 recreationally trained athletes (63 men and 33
women) with a mean age of 27.9 years (SD, 5.7).
Intervention: Men were randomly assigned to receive placebo,
growth hormone (2 mg/d subcutaneously), testosterone (250 mg/wk
intramuscularly), or combined treatments. Women were randomly as-
signed to receive either placebo or growth hormone (2 mg/d).
Measurements: Body composition variables (fat mass, lean body
mass, extracellular water mass, and body cell mass) and physical
performance variables (endurance [maximum oxygen consump-
tion], strength [dead lift], power [jump height], and sprint capacity
[Wingate value]).
Results: Body cell mass was correlated with all measures of
performance at baseline. Growth hormone significantly re-
duced fat mass, increased lean body mass through an increase
in extracellular water, and increased body cell mass in men
when coadministered with testosterone. Growth hormone sig-
nificantly increased sprint capacity, by 0.71 kJ (95% CI, 0.1
to 1.3 kJ; relative increase, 3.9% [CI, 0.0% to 7.7%]) in men
and women combined and by 1.7 kJ (CI, 0.5 to 3.0 kJ;
relative increase, 8.3% [CI, 3.0% to 13.6%]) when coadmin-
istered with testosterone to men; other performance measures
did not significantly change. The increase in sprint capacity
was not maintained 6 weeks after discontinuation of the
drug.
Limitations: Growth hormone dosage may have been lower than
that used covertly by competitive athletes. The athletic significance
of the observed improvements in sprint capacity is unclear, and the
study was too small to draw conclusions about safety.
Conclusion: Growth hormone supplementation influenced body
composition and increased sprint capacity when administered
alone and in combination with testosterone.
Primary Funding Source: The World Anti-Doping Agency.
Ann Intern Med. 2010;152:568-577. www.annals.org
For author affiliations, see end of text.
A
lthough the World Anti-Doping Agency prohibits
the use of growth hormone by competitive athletes,
illicit use of the drug is widespread (1). The belief that
growth hormone enhances performance is based on ob-
servations that it increases lean body mass in extremely
fit persons (2, 3) and reduces body fat and increases lean
mass, fitness, and strength in adults with growth hor-
mone deficiency (4). A recent systematic review (3)
highlighted the lack of evidence that growth hormone
enhances performance. Athletes frequently use growth
hormone with androgenic anabolic steroids (5) on the
basis of similar beliefs and evidence from studies of el-
derly men and men with hypopituitarism that testoster-
one enhances the effects of growth hormone on body
composition (6). However, we do not know whether the
pharmacologic improvements in body composition are
associated with improvements in physical performance
or whether anabolic steroids enhance the effects of
growth hormone in athletes.
We previously reported findings (7) from a double-
blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial designed to
detect changes in biomarkers (serum insulin-like growth
factor [IGF] axis proteins and collagen peptides) in re-
sponse to growth hormone administration as part of an
effort to develop a test for growth hormone doping.
Here, we report findings from prespecified primary anal-
yses of secondary outcome data, which we performed to
assess how growth hormone changes body composition,
whether those changes enhance physical performance,
and whether coadministration of testosterone enhances the
effects of growth hormone on body composition and
performance.
See also:
Print
Editors’ Notes ............................. 569
Summary for Patients ....................... I-44
Web-Only
Appendix
Appendix Tables
Appendix Figures
Conversion of graphics into slides
Annals of Internal Medicine Article
568 © 2010 American College of Physicians