Category Attitude Measures: Exemplars as Inputs
Barbara Loken
Department of Marketing
University of Minnesota
Christopher Joiner
School of Management
George Mason University
Joann Peck
Department of Marketing
University of Wisconsin
The role of exemplars in formation of attitudes toward a category has, surprisingly, been ignored
in prior consumer research. In the present research we seek to develop a better understanding of
the relationship between category exemplars (e.g., the products in a brand category) and overall
attitudes toward the category. Attitude measures that incorporate evaluations of individual
branded products may be useful, both conceptually and practically, and can complement more
traditional multi-attribute measures of attitude. Across 3 studies we present evidence that a com-
posite index of attitudes toward category exemplars, weighted by exemplar typicality, is related
to overall category attitudes, sometimes more strongly than a traditional multi-attribute index.
We also demonstrate that elaboration upon the individual exemplars further strengthens the re-
lationship between category attitudes and this composite index. Theoretical implications for at-
titude theory, as well as managerial implications, are discussed.
More and more companies are managing brands that consist
of multiple products, and recent research in brand categoriza-
tion (e.g., Boush & Loken, 1991; Dawar & Anderson, 1994;
Schmitt & Dube, 1992) highlights the importance of consid-
ering brands as categories of products. As a result, consumers
have become more likely to perceive brand categories in
terms of individual exemplars (i.e., products in the brand
portfolio). The importance of understanding the role of these
individual products in formation of consumers’ attitude to-
ward a brand has increased for brand managers as their port-
folios of products under a single brand name continue to in-
crease (Laforet & Saunders, 1994).
The importance of understanding the role of category
members in category attitude formation extends beyond
brand management to service, product, and social market-
ing contexts. Understanding how consumers’ attitudes to-
ward the airline industry are formed by perceptions of the
individual airlines, how consumers’ attitudes toward
candy bars in general may be related to their perception of
individual candy bars, or how consumers’ attitudes toward
charity organizations are determined by the particular
charity organizations salient to the consumers, are all ques-
tions that hinge on understanding the role of exemplars in
attitude formation. Although recent research has begun to
examine aspects of the relationship between category ex-
emplars and category attitudes (Lord & Lepper, 1999; Sia
et al., 1997, 1999), this research has been limited to social
(rather than product) stimuli, and has not assessed the mea-
surement implications of using multiple category exem-
plars as attitudinal inputs.
The focus of this research is to demonstrate that a compos-
ite index of attitudes toward category exemplars (i.e., the in-
dividual, specific members of a category) is related to the
overall category attitude, in the same way that a composite in-
dex of salient beliefs about the category can be used to predict
overall category attitudes (Fishbein & Ajzen, 1981). Al-
JOURNAL OF CONSUMER PSYCHOLOGY, 12(2), 149–161
Copyright © 2002, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Inc.
Requests for reprints should be sent to Barbara Loken, Department of
Marketing, 3–173 Carlson School Of Management, University of Minne-
sota, 321 19th Avenue South, Minneapolis, MN 55455. E-mail:
bloken@csom.umn.edu