A Sensorimotor Network for the Bodily Self
Francesca Ferri
1
, Francesca Frassinetti
2,3
, Martina Ardizzi
1
,
Marcello Costantini
4,5
, and Vittorio Gallese
1,6
Abstract
■
Neuroscientists and philosophers, among others, have long
questioned the contribution of bodily experience to the consti-
tution of self-consciousness. Contemporary research answers
this question by focusing on the notions of sense of agency
and/or sense of ownership. Recently, however, it has been pro-
posed that the bodily self might also be rooted in bodily motor
experience, that is, in the experience of oneself as instantiating
a bodily structure that enables a specific range of actions. In the
current fMRI study, we tested this hypothesis by making par-
ticipants undergo a hand laterality judgment task, which is
known to be solved by simulating a motor rotation of oneʼs
own hand. The stimulus to be judged was either the partici-
pantʼs own hand or the hand of a stranger. We used this task
to investigate whether mental rotation of pictures depicting
oneʼs own hands leads to a different activation of the sensori-
motor areas as compared with the mental rotation of pictures
depicting anotherʼs hand. We revealed a neural network for
the general representation of the bodily self encompassing
the SMA and pre-SMA, the anterior insula, and the occipital
cortex, bilaterally. Crucially, the representation of oneʼs own
dominant hand turned out to be primarily confined to the left
premotor cortex. Our data seem to support the existence of a
sense of bodily self encased within the sensorimotor system.
We propose that such a sensorimotor representation of the
bodily self might help us to differentiate our own body from
that of others.
■
INTRODUCTION
In everyday life, we move, see, and feel our body and
have no doubt that it is our own. Any experience of
our body provides us with a variety of information related
to it, such as our visual, tactile, and, more generally, physi-
ological state. Besides the distinction between extero-
ceptive, interoceptive, and proprioceptive awareness,
what is the basic experience of our body as a bodily self?
What enables us to implicitly distinguish our body from
other human bodies (Ferri, Frassinetti, Costantini, &
Gallese, 2011; Frassinetti, Ferri, Maini, Benassi, & Gallese,
2011; Frassinetti et al., 2009, 2010; Frassinetti, Maini,
Romualdi, Galante, & Avanzi, 2008)? Recently, it has been
proposed that the bodily self can be conceived as motor
in nature (Gallese & Sinigaglia, 2010; Legrand, 2006), that
is, based on the experience of our own body parts
according to their motor potentialities, as they are repre-
sented in a motor bodily format (see Gallese & Sinigaglia,
2011). Accordingly, Smith (2007) explained the concept
of bodily self as follows: “The bodily self is a physical
agent. Knowledge of oneself as bodily is fundamentally
knowledge of oneself as agentive; such knowledge is
grounded in both experience of oneself as instantiating
a bodily structure that affords a limited range of actions,
and experience of oneself as a physical agent that tries to
perform a limited range of actions over time” (p. 4).
The existence of such motor-experience-based repre-
sentation of the bodily self has been investigated at the
behavioral level in a previous study from our group (Ferri
et al., 2011). In that study, right-handed participants
underwent a laterality judgment task using rotated hand
stimuli, where the hand to be judged could either be the
participantʼs own hand or another personʼs hand. The
results showed faster RTs when judging oneʼs right hand
compared with all the other hand stimuli, regardless of
the magnitude of the rotation. According to previous
studies (Frassinetti et al., 2008, 2009, 2010), we named
this effect “self-advantage. ” Moreover, Ferri and col-
leagues (2011) found that self-advantage does not emerge
when participants are asked to explicitly recognize the
owner of the observed hand. On the basis of these
empirical data, we argued in favor of the assumption that
an implicit motor representation of the bodily self exists
and that it might help us in distinguishing oneʼs own from
othersʼ body, thus leading to the effect of self-advantage.
In this fMRI study, we tested the hypothesis that the
sensorimotor system plays a pivotal role in the implicit
self/other distinction during the laterality judgment task
and, more specifically, in the self-advantage for right
hand in right-handed participants.
We adopted the laterality judgment task because it is
now accepted that, to perform it, one simulates a motor
1
University of Parma,
2
University of Bologna,
3
IRCCS - Istituto
Scientifico di Castel Goffredo, Mantova, Italy,
4
University G.
dʼAnnunzio, Chieti, Italy,
5
Foundation University G. dʼAnnunzio,
Chieti, Italy,
6
Italian Institute of Technology
© 2012 Massachusetts Institute of Technology Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 24:7, pp. 1584–1595