Removing individual rats affects indicators of welfare in
the remaining group members
Oliver Burman
a,
⁎
, Diane Owen
b
, Usama AbouIsmail
a,c
, Mike Mendl
a
a
Centre for Behavioural Biology, University of Bristol, UK
b
Central Science Laboratory, York, UK
c
Department of Hygiene, Husbandry and Zoonoses, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Mansoura University, Mansoura, Egypt
Received 22 August 2006; received in revised form 26 July 2007; accepted 2 August 2007
Abstract
The removal of individuals from social groups, e.g. in order to maintain appropriate stocking densities in groups of rapidly growing young
laboratory rats, is often necessary. However, such removals may be stressful and few studies have investigated their effects on the behaviour,
physiology and welfare of the remaining group members. In this study we investigated this issue for rats housed at different stocking densities by
observing behaviour and recording faecal corticosterone metabolite levels both before and after removal. We found that, irrespective of stocking
density, the rats remaining in the home cage significantly increased agonistic behaviour, audible vocalization, aggressive grooming, bar-chewing
and climbing behaviour following removal of their cage-mates, and that these behavioural changes were associated with a highly significant post-
removal increase in their faecal corticosterone metabolite levels. Taking the behavioural and physiological results together, it appears that the
removal of individuals from groups of young laboratory rats resulted in social stress, and thus an apparent impairment of welfare.
© 2007 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Animal welfare; Laboratory rat; Social disruption; Social stress
1. Introduction
The social environment of a gregarious species such as the
laboratory rat [1] is likely to have a major influence upon its
welfare. Social isolation [2], over-crowding [3] and group
composition [4] all appear able to affect behavioural and
physiological indicators of welfare. It is therefore possible that
standard husbandry procedures that disrupt the social environ-
ment, for instance through the disturbance of social odours (e.g.
cage cleaning), the introduction of stressful procedures (e.g.
handling) or via change to the composition of individuals
within a cage, are also able to impact upon rat welfare [2]. Yet,
whilst there has been some investigation into the potentially
disruptive effect on the social environment, and thus welfare, of
both cage cleaning [5] and handling [6,7], there has been little
research into the effect of changing group composition on
laboratory rat welfare.
A Council of Europe proposal to provide newly weaned rats
with smaller space allowances when housed in larger cages will
result in animals being raised at higher stocking densities in larger
groups comprised of more litters [8]. In order to maintain the
appropriate stocking densities in groups of rapidly growing wean-
ling rats, such housing systems will inevitably require the removal
of a proportion of individuals at particular time intervals. The
removal of individuals from social groups will also frequently occur
as young rats are shipped out to laboratories from breeding
establishments, and when rats are removed for either experimental
procedures or due to illness. During the removal process, individual
rats are arbitrarily selected to be removed. We were therefore
interested to see whether or not such removal – incorporating both
the process of removal itself and the resulting change to group
size – affects the social behaviour of the remaining rats, and
whether it impacts on behavioural and physiological indicators of
their welfare.
Previous research into the effect of changing group com-
position on laboratory rat welfare has focused on either
Physiology & Behavior 93 (2008) 89 – 96
⁎
Corresponding author. Division of Farm Animal Science, Department of
Clinical Veterinary Science, University of Bristol, Langford House, Langford
BS40 5DU, UK. Tel.: +44 1179289571; fax: +44 1179289582.
E-mail address: oliver.burman@bristol.ac.uk (O. Burman).
0031-9384/$ - see front matter © 2007 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.physbeh.2007.08.001