Journal of Chromatography A, 1151 (2007) 115–120
Spiral coils for counter-current chromatography using aqueous
polymer two-phase systems
Y.H. Guan
∗
, J. Smulders, D. Fisher, I.A. Sutherland
Brunel Institute for Bioengineering, Brunel University West London, Uxbridge, Middlesex UB8 3PH, UK
Available online 8 January 2007
Abstract
Retention properties of polyethylene glycol–phosphate aqueous two-phase systems in a spiral coil (5 mm I.D.) on Type-J synchronous counter-
current chromatographic devices have been compared for the elution mode where the lower phase is the mobile phase and flows from the inside
head terminal. This was achieved with the aid of digital imaging under stroboscopic illumination, an image analysis and measurement of the
displaced volume of the stationary phase. For the spiral coil, high and stable stationary phase retention at mobile phase flow rates up to 64 ml/min
has been obtained. Wave-like disturbance of the interface near the proximal point was observed and analyses have been made for possible use in
protein separation.
© 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Counter-current chromatography; Aqueous two-phase systems; Spiral column holders; Polyethylene glycol; PEG; Stroboscopic imaging
1. Introduction
Counter-current chromatography (CCC) is a support-free
form of liquid–liquid chromatography using two immiscible
liquid phases; typically with a stationary phase and a mobile
phase [1,2]. For separation and purification of natural and syn-
thetic products using CCC, a large array of applications has
been developed and/or identified [3]. A pre-requisite for suc-
cessful separation of targeted molecules using high-speed CCC
(HSCCC) has been good retention of the stationary phase [4].
For biochemical and bioengineering applications, aqueous
polymer two-phase systems (ATPS) have been shown to pro-
vide a benign environment for separating and purifying bioactive
macromolecules (e.g. protein, DNA and RNA) and bio-particles
(plasmids, sub-cellular membranes) with potential to scale up
as a bioengineering downstream process [5–7]. Clearly aqueous
two-phase systems have potential for use in CCC [8].
However, for some time there have been difficulties in using
ATPS in the most common multilayer CCC coils on Type-J
HSCCC. The main concern has been the unpredictably low lev-
els of retention for stationary phase [3], especially for high
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +44 1895 267113; fax: +44 1895 274608.
E-mail address: hugh.guan@brunel.ac.uk (Y.H. Guan).
value multilayer coils [9]. Additionally, the stationary phase
shows gradual loss over several hours [10]. It has been suggested
that this results from the formation of an emulsion between the
heavy and light phases of an ATPS, due to the low interfacial
tension and high viscosity of the polymer-rich phase [8].
To reduce the problem of low stationary phase retention for
ATPS mounted on Type-J synchronous CCC device, it appears
that the use of coils with low value in combination with low
mobile phase flow rate might lead to an improved retention (e.g.
S
f
ca. 30% and flow rate ca. 0.5 ml/min for I.D. 1.6 mm and
value close to 0.3 coil) [8].
Another approach to increase the retention of the station-
ary phase has been to develop new CCC devices other than the
Type-J and, broadly speaking, the most successful devices for
such use with ATPS by Ito [11] have been those termed as X-
axis CCC, where the axes of the rotation for the column holder
and the revolution of the rotor cross each other. Compared with
Type-J CCC, the X-axis CCC devices are more cumbersome
and complicated, and are less appealing to the commercial end
users, as the scaling-up of the X-axis CCC devices for large-
scale separation processes would be both costly and technically
complicated. The general dilemma with the use of ATPS has
been that, on one hand the Type-X CCC devices have offered
more success in separating proteins and enzymes than the Type-
J CCC, but on the other hand, the market interests have been on
0021-9673/$ – see front matter © 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.chroma.2006.12.097