"
#$
%&’()*+)%# ,’’#)-. /- ,)(0/1*2’ 0*3)/,’#04 *-3 0’,/#’ %’-%)-. *&&+)(*#)/-%5 %*- 67*-5 &7’0#/ 0)(/5 ,*0($ 85 9::;<
!bstract!"# %&’( )&*) +, -./’01’0*)-.2 +0-2&).#%%
)#31#0*)40# 3#*%40#3#.)% *) ’5567#.-)& *.28#%9 )&# *//40*/, ’5
8-.#*0 %)*)-%)-/*8 0#)0-#:*8% ’5 )#31#0*)40# *.; (*)#0 :*1’0
;#.%-), 10’5-8#% /*. +# -310’:#;< =&-% -310’:#3#.) -% 8-3-)#; )’
/8#*0 %>, /*%#% (�# 3#*%40#3#.)% *) *88 *.28#% 0#10#%#.) )&#
%*3# *)3’%1�-/ /’.;-)-’.%< "# 10#%#.) /’.)0-+4)-’. 54./)-’.%
*.; #00’0 *318-5-/*)-’. 5*/)’0% )’ %&’( &’( )&# ’5567#.-)&
3#*%40#3#.)% *55#/) )&# 0#)0-#:*8 1#05’03*./#<
"# *8%’ %&’( )&*) +, /’3+-.-.2 +0-2&).#%% )#31#0*)40#
3#*%40#3#.)% .#*0 )&# ??<?@A6BC7 (*)#0 :*1’0 8-.# (-)&
3#*%40#3#.)% .#*0 )&# DE@<@D6BC7 8-.# -.)’ * 1&,%-/*8 0#)0-#:*89
)&# *//40*/, ’5 )&# 0#)0-#:#; (*)#0 :*1’0 ;#.%-), 10’5-8# 5’0 :#0,
8’( (*)#0 :*1’0 /’.;-)-’.% /*. +# %-2.-5-/*.)8, -310’:#;<
)< )-#0/37(#)/-
#=> *?@ABC=>DEF 0GHEG?EAI ,>GBJD>@>I? K*0,L &DAMDG@
=GB AC>DG?>H G ?N>OP>QF=GII>O @EFDANGP> DGHEA@>?>D CDAREO>D
K,10&L STU BEIF> V>WDJGDX 9::Y G? E?B -AD?= %OAC> AR *OGBZG
K-%*L RE>OH BE?> I>GD [GDDAN5 *OGBZG< #=> ,10& =GB REP>
F=GII>OB EI ?=> 99Q ?A 8:Q.$\ DGIM> GIH B>P>I F=GII>OB EI ?=>
]:Q ?A ;:Q.$\ DGIM> ?=G? GD> JB>H ?A H>DEP> P>D?EFGO CDAREO>B AR
NG?>D PGCAD H>IBE?X GIH ?>@C>DG?JD>5 GB N>OO GB ?=> EI?>MDG?>H
CD>FECE?GWO> NG?>D PGCAD GIH FOAJH OE^JEH NG?>D CG?=5 G? ]Q
@EIJ?> EI?>DPGOB< #=>B> CDAREO>B GD> G PGOJGWO> BJCCO>@>I? ?A
?=> FAOOAFG?>H DGHEABAIH>B OGJIF=>H ,AIHGXQVDEHGX5 AIF> C>D
HGX5 G? 98:: 7#(<
(AI?AJDB AR ?>@C>DG?JD> GIH NG?>D PGCAD H>IBE?X AW?GEI>H
WX JBEIM ?=> ,10& GD> CD>B>I?>H EI VEM< T5 D>P>GOEIM H>?GEOB
AR G RDAI?GO CGBBGM>< )I FAI?DGB? ?A DGHEABAIH>B5 ?=> ,10&
CDAPEH>B BJWB?GI?EGOOX E@CDAP>H ?>@CADGO D>BAOJ?EAI WJ?
FAGDB>D P>D?EFGO D>BAOJ?EAI ?=G? H>FOEI>B EI CDACAD?EAI ?A ?=>
=>EM=? GWAP> MDAJIH O>P>O< * FAIB>^J>IF> AR H>FOEIEIM
D>BAOJ?EAI NE?= =>EM=? EB ?=G? ?>@C>DG?JD> EIP>DBEAIB5 GB
EOOJB?DG?>H EI VEM< T5 GIH B=GDC NG?>D PGCAD MDGHE>I?B FGI W>
HERREFJO? RAD CGBBEP> CDAREO>DB ?A D>BAOP> GFFJDG?>OX< )I ?=EB
#=EB NADZ NGB BJCCAD?>H WX ?=> (OE@G?> (=GIM> 0>B>GDF= 3EPEBEAI5
7<%< 3>CGD?@>I? AR ’I>DMX5 /RREF> AR %FE>IF>5 /RREF> AR [EAOAMEFGO GIH
’IPEDAI@>I?GO 0>B>GDF=5 JIH>D FAI?DGF? 1Q8TQT:"Q’IMQ8_5 GB CGD? AR ?=>
*?@ABC=>DEF 0GHEG?EAI ,>GBJD>@>I? &DAMDG@< *DMAII> -G?EAIGO +GWADG?ADX
EB AC>DG?>H WX #=> 7IEP>DBE?X AR (=EFGMA RAD ?=> 7< %< 3>CGD?@>I? AR ’I>DMX<
CGC>D5 N> EIP>B?EMG?> E@CDAPEIM ?=> P>D?EFGO D>BAOJ?EAI AR
?>@C>DG?JD> GIH NG?>D PGCAD H>IBE?X D>?DE>PGOB WX GHHEIM ARRQ
\>IE?= @>GBJD>@>I?B< 1> GOBA EIP>B?EMG?> ?=> W>I>RE?B AR
GHHEIM @>GBJD>@>I?B I>GD T_8 .$\ RAD E@CDAPEIM ?=> NG?>D
PGCAD H>IBE?X CDAREO> D>?DE>PGO<
))< ,7+#)Q*-.+’ 0’#0)’2*+%
)I GHHE?EAI ?A \>IE?=5 WDEM=?I>BB ?>@C>DG?JD>B GD> @>GBJD>H
G? >O>PG?EAI GIMO>B AR 98<;‘5 T"<]‘5 GIH T;<;‘ BX@@>?DEFGOOX
GWAJ? ?=> \>IE?= RAD GOO aQWGIH K99<98]5 98<:8]5 98<_8]5
9;<98]5 GIH 8:<: .$\L GIH 2QWGIH K]T<9]5 ]9<9_5 ]8<_]5
]Y<"Y5 ];<;;5 ]b<9"5 ]_<_: .$\L F=GII>OB< #=>B> GIMO>B
FADD>BCAIH ?A GED @GBB>B Kc TdBEIK>O>PLL AR 9<]5 8<:5 GIH 8<]<
*O?=AJM= ?=>B> GIMO>B N>D> B>O>F?>H ?A CDAPEH> HG?G RAD
?ECCEIMQFJDP> FGOEWDG?EAIB AR ?=> aQWGIH F=GII>OB S9U5 ?=>X
@GX GOBA CDAPEH> G @>GIB ?A E@CDAP> ?=> P>D?EFGO D>BAOJ?EAI AR
?=> D>?DE>P>H CDAREO>B S85YU H>BCE?> IA? W>EIM AC?E@GOOX B>O>F?>H
RAD ?=EB CJDCAB><
A. Retrieval Development
1> H>P>OAC>H a priori B?G?EB?EFGO D>?DE>PGOB RAD ?>@C>DG?JD>
GIH NG?>D PGCAD H>IBE?X CDAREO>B WX JBEIM \>IE?=
@>GBJD>@>I?B AIOX GIH WX JBEIM \>IE?= COJB ARRQ\>IE?=
@>GBJD>@>I?B GB RAOOANB< 2GEBGOG 0%": DGHEABAIH>B OGJIF=>H
HJDEIM 9::9Q9::] N>D> EICJ? ?A G @EFDANGP> DGHEG?EAI
?DGIBR>D @AH>O S]U ?A FA@CJ?> WDEM=?I>BB ?>@C>DG?JD>B G? ?=>
?N>OP> @>GBJD>@>I? RD>^J>IFE>B GIH RAJD @>GBJD>@>I?
GIMO>B< #=> @AH>O EIFADCADG?>B ?=> 0AB>IZDGI\ GWBADC?EAI
@AH>O RAD AeXM>I GIH NG?>D PGCAD S;5bU5 @AHERE>H ?A JB> G
IGDDAN>D =GORQNEH?= RAD ?=> 99Q.$\ NG?>D PGCAD OEI> S_5"U GIH
?=> ,#Q(a3 NG?>D PGCAD FAI?EIJJ@ RAD@JOG?EAI ST:U< aQ
WGIH WDEM=?I>BB ?>@C>DG?JD>B N>D> ?DGIBRAD@>H ?A ACGFE?X WX
JBEIM @>GI DGHEG?EAI ?>@C>DG?JD>B RAD >GF= RD>^J>IFX GIH
GIMO> RE??>H ?A BJDRGF> ?>@C>DG?JD>5 CD>BBJD>5 GIH D>OG?EP>
=J@EHE?X< .GJBBEGI IAEB> K@>GI c : a5 B?GIHGDH H>PEG?EAI c
:<] aL NGB GHH>H ?A ?=> FGOFJOG?>H WDEM=?I>BB ?>@C>DG?JD>B ?A
BE@JOG?> GI GF?JGO EIB?DJ@>I?< #=> a priori HG?G N>D> HEPEH>H
EI?A RAJD C>DEAHBf BCDEIM K,GDF=Q,GXL5 BJ@@>D K6JI>Q
*JMJB?L5 RGOO K%>C?>@W>DQ-AP>@W>DL5 GIH NEI?>D K3>F>@W>DQ
0>?DE>PGOB AR *?@ABC=>DEF #>@C>DG?JD> GIH
1G?>D 2GCAD &DAREO>B EI ?=> *DF?EF
6G@>B (< +EOg>MD>I
T
5 ,GDEG &< (GH>HHJ
T
5 GIH *IHD>N &G\@GIX
9
T
*DMAII> -G?EAIGO +GWADG?ADX5 "b:: %AJ?= (GBB *P>IJ>5 *DMAII>5 )+ ;:Y8"5 7%*
#>O< hTQ;8:Q9]9Q"]Y:5 ’@GEOf gFOEOg>MD>IiGIO<MAP
9
&DA%>IBEIM5 )IF<5 T:b %JIH>DOGIH 0AGH5 *@=>DB?5 ,* :T::95 7%*