Effects of Flow Strain on Triple Flame Propagation
HONG G. IM*
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA
and
JACQUELINE H. CHEN
Combustion Research Facility, Sandia National Laboratories, Livermore, CA 94551, USA
The primary objective of this study is to determine the effect of strain rate and scalar dissipation rate on the
instantaneous local displacement speed at the triple flame edge. This is accomplished by performing direct
numerical simulations of a hydrogen-air triple flame subjected to an unsteady strain field induced by a pair of
counter-rotating vortices. It is observed that the triple flames maintain a positive displacement speed when the
vortex strength is weak, such that they penetrate into the channel between the vortices. For the stronger vortex
cases, the intense compressive strain field induced by the vortex pair yields a negative displacement speed and
partial quenching of the leading edge of the flame in an extreme case. The displacement speed variations are
analyzed in terms of curvature, and effective Karlovitz and Damko ¨hler numbers. It is found that the triple flame
tip speed is predominantly governed by the curvature-induced compressive strain rather than by scalar
dissipation rate. As a result, the displacement speed measured at the triple flame tip exhibits a strong
correlation with flame stretch and curvature, and not with scalar dissipation rate. The correlation with flame
stretch is similar to results found in earlier studies of turbulent premixed flames, suggesting that the propagation
aspects of triple flames are the same as for a premixed flame. The trailing diffusion flame essentially has
minimal impact on the propagation of the leading edge. A secondary observation is that for real chemical
systems, ambiguity in the definition of the “leading edge” can lead to significant differences in the propagation
response to strain. For instance, the displacement speed measured at the maximum heat release location rather
than at the leading edge remains positive throughout the entire duration of interaction. This suggests that care
should be taken in identifying the triple flame speed subjected to a large strain field. © 2001 by The
Combustion Institute
INTRODUCTION
Triple flames, or more broadly known as edge
flames, have recently attracted strong research
interest because of their practical relevance to
turbulent diffusion flame stabilization, flame
spread, and autoignition. An earlier study [1]
demonstrated a formal mathematical analysis of
the effects of strain rate on the propagation
speed of a triple flame, thereby first identifying
the existence of positive and negative speed,
which was later termed ignition and extinction
fronts, respectively. More recent studies have
focused on the effects of various parameters,
such as heat release [2] or Lewis number [3]
effects on flame propagation. Spatial and tem-
poral instability issues have also been consid-
ered [4, 5]. A recent study of direct numerical
simulation [6] (see also [7]) confirmed the exis-
tence of negative edge flame speed in response
to unsteady strain induced by a pair of vortices.
All of these studies, however, adopted a one-
step, two-species chemistry model to simplify
the analysis. Consideration of detailed chemis-
try has been addressed in recent direct numer-
ical simulations of methanol-air [8], methane-
air [9], and hydrogen-air [10] systems.
In a recent study [10], the structure and
propagation characteristics of hydrogen-air tri-
ple flames were investigated. Consideration of
full hydrogen chemistry revealed the detailed
structure of major and minor species concentra-
tion and reaction rates within the triple flame. It
was shown that, because of its important role in
chain branching and in the three-body recombi-
nation heat release reaction, the reaction rate of
H atom was found to be the best indicator to
demarcate the three branches of the flame
structure. For the freely propagating triple
flames, the enhancement of the stabilization
speed, defined as the flame speed with respect
to the far-upstream flow, was found to be pri- * Corresponding author. E-mail: hgim@umich.edu
COMBUSTION AND FLAME 126:1384 –1392 (2001)
0010-2180/01/$–see front matter © 2001 by The Combustion Institute
PII S0010-2180(01)00261-9 Published by Elsevier Science Inc.