Int J Soc Welfare 2003: 12: 221– 228
© Blackwell Publishing Ltd and the International Journal of Social Welfare 2003.
Published by Blackwell Publishing, 9600 Garsington Road, Oxford OX4 2DQ, UK and 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148, USA 221
INTERNATIONAL
JOURNAL OF
SOCIAL WELFARE
ISSN 1369-6866
Vandevelde S, Vanderplasschen W, Broekaert E. Cultural
responsiveness in substance-abuse treatment: a qualitative
study using professionals’ and clients’ perspectives
Int J Soc Welfare 2003: 12: 221–228 © Blackwell Publishing,
2003
As a result of the growing number of ethnic and cultural
minority clients in substance-abuse treatment during the last
decades, a culturally responsive approach has become more
and more imperative. In this article the statements (n = 1330)
of professionals (n = 11) and clients (n = 11) representing the
substance-abuse treatment centres in the region of Ghent and
its suburbs (Belgium) are analysed. In focus are the specific
treatment needs of ethnically and culturally diverse substance-
abusing clients and the difficulties consequent to treating
this target group. Possible approaches to overcoming these
difficulties are highlighted and elaborated by means of semi-
structured interviews and focus groups. The participants in the
study stress the importance of an integrated approach, with
special attention given to the factors that can promote or
jeopardise treatment.
Stijn Vandevelde, Wouter Vanderplasschen,
Eric Broekaert
Department of Orthopedagogics, Ghent University, Belgium
Blackwell Publishing Ltd Oxford, UK IJSW Int J Soc Welfare 1369-6866 © Blackwell Publishers Ltd and the International Journal of Social Welfare 2003 2003 12 3 1 000 Original Article Cultural responsiveness in substance-abuse treatment Vandevelde, Vanderplassschen & Broekhart
Cultural responsiveness in
substance-abuse treatment:
a qualitative study using
professionals’ and clients’
perspectives
Key words: cultural responsiveness, substance-abuse treatment,
ethnic and cultural diversity, qualitative research
Stijn Vandevelde, Department of Orthopedagogics, Ghent
University, H. Dunantlaan 2, B-9000 Ghent, Belgium
E-mail: stijn.vandevelde@rug.ac.be
Accepted for publication January 20, 2003
Introduction
As outlined in the introductory article to this mini-
symposium contribution, therapeutic communities have
always considered cultural diversity as an essential
concept within their treatment approach (De Leon,
Melnick, Schoket & Jainchill, 1993). Currently, because
of the increasing number of ethnic minority clients in
substance-abuse treatment in general (Finn, 1994,
1996), the need for and implementation of a culturally
responsive treatment has become more urgent and
widespread (Argeriou & Daley, 1997; Ellis, 1999;
Kline, 1996; Terrell, 1993; Westermeyer, 1996). In this
context, it is worthwhile noting that the organisation of
treatment centres is almost always modelled after the
dominant (autochthon) culture (Lee, 1994). Research
points out that ethnic minorities often fail to make use
of the existing treatment facilities (Ashruf & van der
Eijnden, 1996; Longshore, Grills, Anglin & Annon,
1997) and that there is a disproportionate ethnic
distribution in some treatment centres, especially in
those with a high threshold (e.g. therapeutic
communities) (Braam, Verbraeck & van de Wijngaert,
1998; De Leon, Melnick, Schoket & Jainchill, 1993;
Vandevelde, Vanderplasschen & Broekaert, 2000).
Furthermore, minority clients are less likely to
successfully complete treatment (Finn, 1994, 1996)
and more likely to experience specific difficulties due
to typical characteristics of the (traditional) treatment
system, methods and techniques (Tucker, 1985).
To cope with these difficulties, recent research has
revealed the importance of taking the specific needs of
minority clients and other ethno-cultural factors into
account when treating culturally diverse client groups
(Jackson, Stephens & Smith, 1997; Rounds-Bryant,
Kristiansen & Hubbard, 1999; Varma & Siris, 1996).
Therapeutic communities and other treatment centres
also share these concerns and insist on the necessity
of specification. First of all, substance-abuse treat-
ment centres are not equally distributed over different
cities and regions in Belgium, regardless of need
(Vanderplasschen, De Bourdeaudhuij & Van Oost,
2002); moreover, treatment is influenced by many
cultural and traditional factors. Important differences
can exist – such as country of origin, religion, values
and beliefs – amongst persons with culturally diverse