Muscle contraction force and fatigue: effects
on mismatch negativity
Maria D. Evstigneeva
a
, Alexander A. Alexandrov
a
, Svend Erik Mathiassen
b
and Eugene Lyskov
b
Muscle load can affect the performance of concurrent
cognitive task. This effect is often explained by limited
resources in the voluntary attention system. To examine
whether earlier stages of cognitive information processing
might be affected, we recorded the mismatch negativity
component (MMN) of the auditory event-related brain
potential before, during and after sustained handgrip
at 7 and 30% of maximal voluntary contraction. MMN is
an index of automatic detection of a deviating auditory
event. MMN was not affected by force level. However,
its amplitude at fronto-central sites decreased during
the fatiguing 30% contraction, while it tended to increase
during the light 7% work. Thus, muscle fatigue may
affect auditory information processing at preattentive
and preconscious stages, which could modify cognitive
performance. NeuroReport 00:000–000
c
2010 Wolters
Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
NeuroReport 2010, 00:000–000
Keywords: dual task, event-related potentials, force production, isometric
contraction, mismatch negativity, muscle fatigue, preattentive auditory
information processing
a
Department of Higher Nervous Activity and Psychophysiology, Saint Petersburg
State University, Saint Petersburg, Russian Federation and
b
Centre for
Musculoskeletal Research, University of Ga ¨vle, Ga ¨ vle, Sweden
Correspondence to Maria D. Evstigneeva, Department of Higher Nervous Activity
and Psychophysiology, Faculty of Biology and Soil Sciences, Saint Petersburg
State University, Universitetskaja nab 7/9, Saint Petersburg 199034,
Russian Federation
Tel: +7921 389 23 67; fax: +7812 328 97 03;
e-mail: maria.evstigneeva@gmail.com
Received 25 August 2010 accepted 21 September 2010
Introduction
Sustained muscle load and fatigue has been shown in
some studies to impair cognitive task performance [1–4],
while an improvement has also been suggested [1,5]. The
neurophysiologic mechanisms underlying such associa-
tions however, have not yet been systematically investi-
gated. The voluntary attention system with its limited
resources is often thought to be a bottleneck at which the
interaction between the motor and cognitive processes
takes place (e.g. [2,4]). When more effort has to be
invested in maintaining a physical work load in spite of
fatigue, fewer resources are available for cognitive tasks.
On the other hand, as suggested by, for example, Bills [5],
cognitive performance could also improve when carrying
out a phsyically demanding task, either due to ‘nutritive’
effects following from an increase in vital processes such
as blood supply and breathing, or/and because of direct
neural interactions, including lowering of thresholds by
afferent flow or preparatory activity from activated neuro-
muscular systems.
A useful investigatory tool for shedding some light on the
association between motor and cognitive performance is
the event-related brain potential (ERP) technique. Diff-
erent ERP components are believed to reflect specific
stages of perceptual, cognitive, and motor processes,
including attention-related aspects. Earlier ERP research
has shown that the amplitude of the P3b component
appears to reflect voluntary attention resource allocation
in a dual task, when individuals perform cognitive and
motor task simultaneously [6].
Not only the voluntary attention level, however, but also
earlier stages of information processing may be affected
by muscle load and fatigue, with a modulated cognitive
task performance as the result. To test the latter idea, we
examined the effect of a sustained muscle contraction on
the mismatch negativity (MMN) ERP component, which
is believed to reflect the automatic, preattentive and
preconscious, response to detectable changes in auditory
stimulation, and to be involved in attention-switching
mechanisms (for reviews see [7–9]). MMN is an en-
hanced negativity in the ERP to rare ‘deviant’ acoustic
events that occur in a sequence of regular ‘standard’
events, as compared with ERP to those ‘standards’, at a
latency of 100–250 ms after standard-deviant divergence
point. MMN appears even when no specific attention is
paid to the stimuli. Thus, the examination of MMN may
help to differentiate between early (more automatic) and
later (more effort demanding) processes.
A modulation of the MMN component during muscle
contractions would indicate that force production and/or
fatigue interferes with cognitive information processing
at a very early, preattentive and preconscious stage.
This study aimed at exploring early associations between
force, fatigue and information processing by comparing
the MMN before, during, and after sustained muscle
contractions at two force levels, leading to different levels
of fatigue.
This study was carried out in Saint Petersburg State University, Universitetskaja
nab 7/9, Saint Petersburg 199034, Russian Federation.
Motor systems 1
0959-4965 c 2010 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins DOI: 10.1097/WNR.0b013e328340cc66
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.