Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Science and Technology of Nuclear Installations
Volume 2012, Article ID 173637, 19 pages
doi:10.1155/2012/173637
Research Article
SPES3 Facility RELAP5 Sensitivity Analyses on
the Containment System for Design Review
Andrea Achilli,
1
Cinzia Congiu,
1
Roberta Ferri,
1
Fosco Bianchi,
2
Paride Meloni,
2
Davor Grgi´ c,
3
and Milorad Dzodzo
4
1
SIET S.p.A., UdP, Via Nino Bixio 27/c, 29121 Piacenza, Italy
2
ENEA, UTFISSM, Via Martiri di Monte Sole 4, 40129 Bologna, Italy
3
FER, University of Zagreb, Unska 3, 10000 Zagreb, Croatia
4
Research and Technology Unit, Westinghouse Electric Company LLC, Cranberry Township, PA 16066, USA
Correspondence should be addressed to Roberta Ferri, ferri@siet.it
Received 11 March 2011; Accepted 27 July 2011
Academic Editor: Alessandro Del Nevo
Copyright © 2012 Andrea Achilli et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
An Italian MSE R&D programme on Nuclear Fission is funding, through ENEA, the design and testing of SPES3 facility at SIET,
for IRIS reactor simulation. IRIS is a modular, medium size, advanced, integral PWR, developed by an international consortium
of utilities, industries, research centres and universities. SPES3 simulates the primary, secondary and containment systems of IRIS,
with 1:100 volume scale, full elevation and prototypical thermal-hydraulic conditions. The RELAP5 code was extensively used in
support to the design of the facility to identify criticalities and weak points in the reactor simulation. FER, at Zagreb University,
performed the IRIS reactor analyses with the RELAP5 and GOTHIC coupled codes. The comparison between IRIS and SPES3
simulation results led to a simulation-design feedback process with step-by-step modifications of the facility design, up to the final
configuration. For this, a series of sensitivity cases was run to investigate specific aspects affecting the trend of the main parameters
of the plant, as the containment pressure and EHRS removed power, to limit fuel clad temperature excursions during accidental
transients. This paper summarizes the sensitivity analyses on the containment system that allowed to review the SPES3 facility
design and confirm its capability to appropriately simulate the IRIS plant.
1. Introduction
The IRIS reactor, with its integral design, is an advanced
engineering solution of the latest LWR technology. Medium-
sized, safe, modular, and economic, it provides a viable
bridge to generation IV and satisfies the GNEP requirements
for grid-appropriate NPPs [1–3].
In the frame of an R&D program on nuclear fission,
funded by the Italian Ministry of Economic Development,
ENEA, as member of the IRIS consortium, is supporting the
design, construction, and testing of the SPES3 ITF at SIET
laboratories [4–6].
The SPES3 design was carried out following the subse-
quent steps: (a) definition of a preliminary facility design,
based on specified system geometry; (b) setup of the
RELAP5 facility model and DBA simulation; (c) comparison
of SPES3 and IRIS results against the same transient;
(d) identification of the main differences and understanding
of related reasons; (e) FSA application to selected thermo-
fluid-dynamic parameters in order to assess and quantify the
discrepancies; (f) updating of the SPES3 design to match
the IRIS behaviour; (g) final result comparison; (h) final
FSA application and assessment of acceptability criteria for
considering SPES3 correctly simulating IRIS.
The above-mentioned process allowed to verify the
SBLOCA PIRT objectives for the IRIS reactor, as defined by
a group of international experts [7]. The Phenomena Iden-
tification and Ranking Table put in evidence the thermal-
hydraulic phenomena playing an important role in operation
of IRIS safety systems. Two figures of merit were considered
fundamental for the accident sequence control: containment
pressure and reactor vessel mass inventory. Sufficient water
in the vessel allows to remove stored energy, and decay heat
without fuel clad temperature excursions and adequate heat