Organizational Readiness for Business Process Outsourcing:
A Model of Determinants and Impact on Outsourcing Success
Sebastian F. Martin
E-Finance Lab
Goethe University, Frankfurt, Germany
smartin@wiwi.uni-frankfurt.de
Daniel Beimborn
Chair of Information Systems and Services
University of Bamberg, Germany
daniel.beimborn@wiai.uni-bamberg.de
Mihir A. Parikh
MIS Department
College of Business Administration
University of Central Florida
mparikh@bus.ucf.edu
Tim Weitzel
Chair of Information Systems and Services
University of Bamberg, Germany
tim.weitzel@wiai.uni-bamberg.de
Abstract
In innovation adoption literature, the important role
of the organizational context as a determinant of
information systems (IS) success has long been pointed
out. Various factors such as top management support,
process formalization, and availability of resources
have been shown to contribute to the successful
implementation of new information systems. By
drawing on relevant insights from IT innovations
literature, our conceptual piece of research aims at
identifying organizational context factors which are
critical for the success of business process outsourcing
(BPO) as part of a firm’s overall Business Process
Management activities. More specifically, process
readiness, IT readiness and business management
readiness are proposed to be important dimensions of
organizational readiness for BPO. Furthermore, IT
business alignment, as a routine-based process of
knowledge sharing and creation, is proposed to be a
driver of organizational readiness for BPO.
1. Introduction
Business Process Management (BPM) is
increasingly attracting interests of both practitioners
and researchers, as it promises to improve business
agility and operational governance by discovering,
analyzing, modeling, simulating, optimizing, executing
and governing business processes using well-defined
methods, policies, metrics, practices, and software
tools. Despite its relative recentness, business process
outsourcing (BPO) is emerging to be one of the most
promising instruments of BPM that optimizes
performance in both core and non-core business
processes. It aims to develop mutually beneficial
interorganizational alliances among firms based on the
level of competence in various business processes. The
emergence of standardized and open IT platforms in
recent years has made such alliances not only
operationally feasible but also economically attractive.
Nevertheless, until now BPO has received little
attention in academic literature [45]. Moreover,
descriptive studies found a significant number of BPO
deals showing serious problems; a survey [60]
conducted in 2004 among Germany’s 500 largest banks
on process performance issues, the role of IT, and
outsourcing tendencies in the credit business found that
among the managers of banks which had already
outsourced (parts of) their credit process, practically no
one was fully contented with the outcomes of the
outsourcing deal. Only 29% of the managers in charge
with the specific process stated to be “rather content”
with the outcomes of BPO. A subsequent study found
that the risk of not achieving expected cost savings
from an outsourcing deal (because the underlying
business case does not contain all prospective costs)
ranged among the top three managerial concerns
regarding business process outsourcing (BPO) [62].
Much of the academic literature on outsourcing
focuses on the outcomes of outsourcing [15]. The
general tenor is that customers can successfully exploit
Proceedings of the 41st Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences - 2008
1530-1605/08 $25.00 © 2008 IEEE 1