J Head Trauma Rehabil
Vol. 29, No. 2, pp. E11–E18
Copyright
c 2014 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
Psychotic Symptoms as Manifestations
of the Posttraumatic Confusional State:
Prevalence, Risk Factors, and
Association With Outcome
Mark Sherer, PhD; Stuart A. Yablon, MD; Todd G. Nick, PhD
Objectives: To (1) determine factors associated with psychotic-type symptoms in persons with moderate or severe
traumatic brain injury (TBI) during early recovery and (2) investigate the prognostic significance of early psychotic-
type symptoms for patient outcome. Setting: Acute neurorehabilitation inpatient unit. Participants: A total of 168
persons with moderate or severe TBI were admitted for inpatient rehabilitation. Of these, 107 had psychotic-type
symptoms on at least 1 examination. One-year productivity outcome was available for 87 of the 107 participants.
Design: Prospective, inception cohort, observational study. Main Measures: Confusion Assessment Protocol, pro-
ductivity outcome at 1 year postinjury. Results: Presence of sleep disturbance, a shorter interval from admission to
assessment, and greater cognitive impairment were associated with a greater incidence of psychotic-type symptoms.
Younger age, more years of education, and lower frequency and severity of psychotic-type symptoms were associated
with a greater likelihood of favorable productivity outcome. Conclusions: We identified risk factors for the occur-
rence of psychotic-type symptoms and extended previous findings regarding the significance of these symptoms for
outcome after TBI. These findings suggest that improved sleep in early TBI recovery may decrease the occurrence
of psychotic-type symptoms. Key words: confusion, delirium, outcome, traumatic brain injury
I
N responsive patients, early recovery from moderate
or severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) is characterized
by disorientation, pervasive cognitive impairments, and
other neurobehavioral deficits.
1
While this period of
recovery has been referred to as posttraumatic amnesia,
Stuss and colleagues
2
noted some phenomenological
similarity to delirium and suggested renaming this phase
as the posttraumatic confusional state (PTCS). They offered
evidence that the key neurobehavioral impairment for
Author Affiliations: TIRR Memorial Hermann, Baylor College of
Medicine, University of Houston Medical School, Houston, Texas
(Dr Sherer); Division of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, University
of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada (Dr Yablon); and Department of
Pediatrics and Biostatistics, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences,
Little Rock (Dr Nick).
This research was supported by US Department of Education National Insti-
tute on Disability and Rehabilitation Research Grants H133A070043 and
H133A020514.
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Corresponding Author: Mark Sherer, PhD, TIRR Memorial Hermann,
1333 Moursund, Houston, TX 77030 (Mark.Sherer@memorialhermann.
org).
DOI: 10.1097/HTR.0b013e318287f894
patients in PTCS is a global disturbance of attentional
functions.
In our program of research on the PTCS, we have de-
veloped a procedure for assessing PTCS, the Confusion
Assessment Protocol (CAP),
3
and have proposed diag-
nostic criteria for PTCS.
3
We have identified 7 key symp-
toms of PTCS: cognitive impairment, disorientation,
fluctuation, restlessness, decreased daytime arousal,
nighttime sleep disturbance, and psychotic-type symp-
toms, and we have demonstrated the frequencies of these
symptoms in confused and nonconfused patients in
early recovery from moderate or severe TBI.
4
Our work
has shown that confusion severity is predictive of early
and late outcome after TBI and, in preliminary results,
that presence or absence of key symptoms of confusion
in the early period postinjury predicts employment out-
come at 1-year postinjury.
4
Finally, we have reported on
the typical patterns of recovery from PTCS.
5
Of par-
ticular note from this line of investigation, we found a
surprisingly high incidence of psychotic-type symptoms
(hallucinations, delusions) in confused patients in early
recovery from moderate or severe TBI with more than
40% of patients showing these symptoms on at least 1 ex-
amination during inpatient brain injury rehabilitation.
4
Copyright © 2014 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
E11