10.1177/009385402237924
CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND BEHAVIOR
Salekin et al. / THE OVERCONTROLLED HOSTILITY SCALE
THE OVERCONTROLLED
HOSTILITY SCALE
An Evaluation of Its Applicability
With an Adolescent Population
KAREN L. SALEKIN
University of Alabama
JAMES R. P. OGLOFF
Morash University and Forensicare
ROBERT G. LEY
Simon Fraser University
RANDALL T. SALEKIN
University of Alabama
The present study examined the validity of Megargee’s Overcontrolled Hostility Scale for use
with a delinquent and violent adolescent population. Archival Minnesota Multiphasic Personal-
ity Inventory (MMPI) data were collected on 18 adolescent murderers, 18 violent (but
nonmurdering) young offenders, and 18 nonviolent youths convicted of property offenses. The
MMPI was administered to a comparison group of 18 adolescent nonoffenders. The homicide
group was divided into two groups based on documented instances of the offender’s aggressive
behavior prior to committing a homicide: the aggressive homicide subgroup and the
nonaggressive homicide subgroup. Moderate but statistically nonsignificant effect sizes were
found between adolescent murderers and all other adolescent groups on the scale. These results
suggest that overcontrolled hostility may be present in adolescent murderers. Implications for
assessment and treatment are discussed.
P
revious research has indicated that adolescent murderers do
not constitute a homogeneous group (Bailey, 1996; Cornell,
Benedek, & Benedek, 1987; Sendi & Blomgren, 1975). In fact, the
limited research pertaining to the clinical assessment of adolescent
murderers reflects the diversity of these young offenders and that of
718
CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND BEHAVIOR, Vol. 29 No. 6, December 2002 718-733
DOI: 10.1177/009385402237924
© 2002 American Association for Correctional Psychology