Paper Offer # 05P-660
Assessment of Corrosivity Associated with Exhaust Gas
Recirculation in a Heavy-Duty Diesel Engine
Michael D. Kass, John F. Thomas, Dane Wilson, and Samuel A. Lewis, Sr.
Oak Ridge National Laboratory
Andy Sarles
Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
Copyright © 2004 SAE International
ABSTRACT
A high-resolution corrosion probe was placed within the
airhorn section of the exhaust gas recirculation (EGR)
loop of a heavy-duty diesel engine. The corrosion rate of
the mild-steel probe elements was evaluated as a
function of fuel sulfur level, EGR fraction, dewpoint
margin, and humidity. No significant corrosion was
observed while running the engine using a No. 2 grade,
< 15ppm sulfur diesel fuel; however, high corrosion rates
were observed on the probe elements when operating
the engine using a standard grade No. 2 diesel fuel
(~350 ppm sulfur) while condensing water in the EGR
loop. The rate of corrosion on the mild steel elements
was found to increase with increasing levels of sulfate in
the condensate. However, the engine conditions
influencing the sulfate level were not clearly identified in
this study.
INTRODUCTION
BACKGROUND
Exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) is being used as a
means of lowering NOx emissions from heavy duty
diesel engines. During this process, a portion of the
exhaust is recirculated back to the cylinder (via the
intake manifold) where the exhaust gas acts as a
diluent. This lowers combustion temperature which
reduces the formation of nitrogen oxides (NOx). EGR is
currently used to meet on-highway NOx emissions for
Tier 3 emission levels for heavy-duty diesel engines.
Very high levels of EGR have been shown to push
combustion to low temperature regimes where both NOx
and PM levels are low. This is currently an area of
intense study.
During the combustion of diesel fuel, corrosive gases
containing sulfur and nitrogen are produced. With EGR
these corrosive gases are returned to the intake
manifold where ambient conditions (such as temperature
and humidity) and coolant conditions are believed to
play a critical role in the formation of highly corrosive
acidic compounds, especially sulfuric acid (1,2).
Development of an in-situ measurement system would
significantly advance the understanding of the corrosion
potential associated with EGR, thereby enabling engine
manufacturers to establish boundary conditions on
engine operation to avoid high levels of corrosion.
SULFURIC ACID FORMATION
During the combustion of sulfur-bearing fuel with excess
air, most of the sulfur is converted into gaseous SO
2
or
absorbed into the particulate matter (PM) emissions. A
small fraction is also converted into gaseous SO
3
(1-4).
Sulfuric acid is primarily formed in diesel exhaust by a
two-step process. In the first step gaseous SO
2
reacts
with oxygen in the exhaust to form SO
3
which is
described as follows:
2SO
2
+ O
2
J 2SO
3
The SO
3
subsequently reacts with moisture in the
exhaust to form sulfuric acid according to the following
reaction:
2SO
3
+ H
2
O J H
2
SO
4
Under typical exhaust conditions sulfuric acid will
condense near temperatures approaching 150
o
C while
water condensation will occur at temperatures close to
25-30
o
C (1-4).
PROBE DESCRIPTION
The corrosion probe used in this study is an electrical
resistance (ER) based probe manufactured by Cormon
Ltd. The probe uses their proprietary CEION technology
to enable high resolution measurement (< 1micron) at
relatively high sample rates (up to 0.25 Hz). A
photograph showing the probe tip is shown in Fig. 1.
The overall diameter of the probe is 2.54 cm and