2015 XVIII AISEM Annual Conference
978-1-4799-8591-3/15/$31.00 ©2015 IEEE
Micromachined Silicon Radiation Sensors – Part 1:
Design And Experimental Characterization
A. Bagolini, M. Boscardin, P. Conci, M. Crivellari,
G. Giacomini, F. Mattedi, C. Piemonte, S. Ronchin,
N. Zorzi
Centro per i Materiali e i Microsistemi
Fondazione Bruno Kessler
Trento, Italy
boscardi@fbk.eu
M.A. Benkechkache, G.-F. Dalla Betta, R. Mendicino,
L. Pancheri, M. Povoli, D.M.S. Sultan
Dipartimento di Ingegneria Industriale
Universita degli Studi di Trento
Trento, Italy
gianfranco.dallabetta@unitn.it
Abstract—Silicon radiation sensors fabricated with
micromachining technologies offer a number of advantages
compared to their planar counterparts, making them appealing
for an increasing number of applications. This paper provides an
overview of the most interesting developments in this field by
Fondazione Bruno Kessler in collaboration with the University of
Trento.
Keywords—silicon radiation sensor; 3D sensors;
micromachining; TCAD simulations
I. INTRODUCTION
In the early 1980’s, the application of the planar process,
derived from microelectronics, represented a key milestone in
the history of silicon radiation sensors [1]. Thirty years later,
another radiation sensor paradigm, based on bulk
micromachining of silicon (e.g., by Deep Reactive Ion Etching
– DRIE), is finally reaching its maturity, paving the way to
several new interesting applications. These devices exploit the
3
rd
dimension within the silicon substrate to offer several
interesting features, either related to the very radiation sensing
properties or to ancillary functions.
The most famous example is that of 3D sensors, where the
electrodes penetrate through the substrate, perpendicularly to
the surface, rather than being confined to the wafer surfaces,
like in planar sensors. This architecture enables the electrode
distance to be decoupled from the sensor thickness, with
significant advantages in terms of low operation voltage, high
speed, and high radiation tolerance [2]. Derived as an extension
of 3D sensor technology, active edges consist of deep trenches
etched by DRIE around the sensor active area and doped to act
as (normally ohmic) electrodes. By doing so, full signal
sensitivity up to a few micrometers from the sensor physical
edge can be obtained. This allows for large area seamlessly
tiled detector matrices, i.e., omitting sensor overlap within the
same layer, with major advantages in the detector assembly [3].
Very thin sensors, that are attractive in high-energy and nuclear
physics e.g., for timing or particle identification, or to improve
the momentum resolution by reducing multiple scattering, can
be obtained by locally thinning the silicon substrate by DRIE
or chemical etching by TMAH or KOH [4]. Microstructured
silicon sensors with high aspect-ratio cavities filled by proper
converting materials (e.g.,
6
LiF,
10
B) are emerging as viable
alternatives to gas based sensors for the detection of thermal
neutrons with high efficiency and low cost, as requested by
several applications like homeland security, forensics, material
science, to cite a few [5]. Very small detection volumes can be
accurately defined by a combination of DRIE and wet etching,
as requested for microdosimetry in synchrotron and particle
therapy and space radiation protection [6]. Other interesting
options, not dealing to the very sensor but rather to related
system issues, are micro-channels for cooling [7], and feed-
through connections similar to TSVs but much deeper [8].
Micromachined sensors are nowadays a hot topic in
radiation detection, but only a few laboratories worldwide have
the capability to manage the related fabrication challenges.
Among them the Center for Material and Microsystems of
Fondazione Bruno Kessler (FBK-CMM), where R&D
activities in this field have been carried out for more than ten
years, mainly in collaboration with the University of Trento
and INFN. Besides the technological challenges, that are
covered in the “Part 2” paper, these devices also call for a
thorough design and TCAD simulation approach, as well as an
extensive experimental characterization, that are here addressed
with some selected examples.
II. SELECTED CASE STUDIES
A. 3D silicon radiation sensors
3D silicon sensors have been developed since 2004 at FBK
using a double-sided approach, that provides several
advantages compared to the original technology pioneered at
Stanford in terms of complexity and processing time. As a
matter of fact this represented a key factor in allowing FBK to
be involved, jointly with CNM (Barcelona, Spain), in the very
first medium volume production of 3D sensors for the ATLAS
Insertable B-Layer (IBL) [9-11].
The unique properties of 3D sensors in terms of high charge
collection efficiency even after very large irradiation fluences
are determined by the short distance in between the deeply
penetrating electrodes, which can effectively attenuate the
detrimental effect of charge trapping [12]. However, other
properties of 3D sensors are affected by surface layout details
to a non-negligible extent [13]: as an example, contrarily to
This work has been partially funded by: (i) the Provincia Autonoma di
Trento through the Project MEMS; (ii) the Italian National Institute for
Nuclear Physics (INFN) through the Projects ATLAS, CMS, P-SUPERB
(CSN1), TREDI, TRIDEAS, VIPIX, HYDE, and PIXFEL (CSN5).