Ann. Zool. Fennici 44: 415–424 ISSN 0003-455X (print), ISSN 1797-2450 (online)
Helsinki 19 December 2007 © Finnish Zoological and Botanical Publishing Board 2007
Relaxed competition during winter may explain the
coexistence of two sympatric Microtus species
Katrine S. Hoset
1
& Harald Steen
1,2
1)
Program for Experimental Behavioral and Population Ecological Research, Department of Biology,
University of Oslo, PB 1050 Blindern, N-0316 Oslo, Norway (e-mail: katrine.hoset@utu.fi)
2)
Norwegian Polar Institute, Hjalmar Johannesens gt 14, N-9296 Tromsø, Norway
Received 13 Feb. 2006, revised version received 30 Oct. 2007, accepted 30 Oct. 2007
Hoset, K. S. & Steen, H. 2007: Relaxed competition during winter may explain the coexistence of
two sympatric Microtus species. — Ann. Zool. Fennici 44: 415–424.
Root voles (Microtus oeconomus) are competitively superior during summer and
locally displace ield voles (M. agrestis). Since the two species co-exist in many areas,
competition may be relaxed or reversed during winter. To assess the competitive
interaction during winter, we used PIT tags to study activity patterns and home range
overlap of the two species in two enclosures with food-supplemented and non-supple-
mented plots during the winter of 2002–2003. Additionally, we established single spe-
cies systems of root-vole and ield-vole populations in the winter of 2004. Home-range
size was smaller and activity lower in ield voles than in root voles, and food supple-
mentation caused an increase in activity in both species. Activity and home-range size
in either species was not affected by the presence of the other. Despite the different
activity patterns of the two species, home range overlap between ield voles and root
voles did not differ from random in the food-supplemented plots. In the non-supple-
mented plots daily overlap was higher than expected. As predicted, we were not able
to detect any interference competition between ield and root voles during winter. This
supports our hypothesis that coexistence between the two may be caused by relaxed
contest competition during winter.
Introduction
In northern habitats with distinct breeding and
non-breeding seasons, seasonal variation in
competitive intensity between species may be
of importance. Studies of bank voles (Myodes
glareolus, previously Clethrionomys glareolus)
and ield voles have shown that aggression levels
in individual encounters are low during the non-
breeding season both in mixed and single spe-
cies communities (reviewed in Eccard & Ylönen
2003). The non-breeding season in the north
is energetically demanding and may not allow
maintenance of intensive competitive interac-
tions. A prerequisite for competition between the
two species is that there is a shortage of some
resource that both depend upon. Korslund and
Steen (2006) found that winter survival of root
voles increased with increased food availability
and we can therefore assume that there are food
shortages during the winter. A study of grey-
sided voles (Myodes rufocanus) supports this
assumption since over-winter rate of population
change was negatively affected by the size of the
This article has been scientifically edited by: Johan Kotze