Influence of the Free Fatty Acids, Water, Temperature, and Reaction
Time on the Catalyst-Free Microwave-Assisted Transesterification of
Triglycerides with 1‑Butanol
Jeroen Geuens,
†,‡
Sergey Sergeyev,
†
Bert U. W. Maes,
†
and Serge M. F. Tavernier*
,‡
†
Department of Chemistry, University of Antwerp, Groenenborgerlaan 171, B-2020 Antwerp, Belgium
‡
Department of Applied Engineering, Karel de Grote University College, Salesianenlaan 30, B-2660 Hoboken, Belgium
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: The influence of the free fatty acids, water, temperature, and reaction time on the catalyst-free microwave-assisted
transesterification of triglycerides with 1-butanol was studied using the response surface modeling (RSM) approach. Stearic acid
and/or water were added to rapeseed oil to construct the model. Afterward, the general applicability of the model was verified
using other triglyceride sources (refined oils as well as waste fats and oils), other free fatty acids, and other alcohols. In most
cases, the model gives a fair approximation of the actual yield of fatty acid alkyl esters; however, the model tends to underestimate
the yield when waste fats and oils are used. Next to that, a significant increase in prediction error was observed when using
branched alcohols. For reactions of 2 h at 234-264 °C, yields over 90% could be reached when using waste fat streams.
1. INTRODUCTION
Whereas fatty acid methyl esters are commonly used as biofuel,
fatty acid alkyl esters of higher alcohols have a wide variety of
applications, such as lubricants, cleaning agents, plasticizers in
the production of plastics, cold flow improvers, or reactive
diluents in the paint industry.
1
Moreover, higher alcohols are
completely miscible with fats and oils, thus leading to a
homogeneous reaction system in which phase-transfer issues do
not occur. Transesterification of triglycerides is typically
performed using homogeneous alkali catalysts. In this process,
large wastewater streams are created because of the necessity to
wash the ester layer.
2
Next to that, the glycerol, which is a
byproduct of the reaction, has to be purified because it will
contain salts from the neutralization of the catalyst. Former
research by our group indicated that the catalyst-free
microwave-assisted transesterification of rapeseed oil with 1-
butanol is possible when high temperature and pressure are
applied, thus eluding washing steps and producing pure
glycerol.
3
However, because of the elevated cost of high-
temperature and high-pressure equipment when working on a
pilot scale or an industrial scale, it is desirable to perform the
transesterification reaction at a lower temperature and pressure.
Moreover, current pilot-scale and industrial-scale microwave
reactors are not capable of reaching 80 bar and 310 °C needed
for the catalyst-free transesterification of rapeseed oil with 1-
butanol.
4
It is known from the literature that the presence of water and
free fatty acids negatively affects the conversion of triglycerides
to fatty acid esters when the reaction is performed using alkali
catalysts.
5-7
However, water and free fatty acids have a positive
influence on the conversion when the transesterification
reaction is performed without a catalyst in supercritical
conditions.
2,8-10
Thus, adding water and free fatty acids or
using low-grade (i.e., low-cost) oils, which typically have a
higher water content and a higher acid value, could create
possibilities to lower the reaction temperature and pressure
while still maintaining a high yield of fatty acid esters.
In this paper, the influence of the reaction temperature,
reaction time, water content, and acid value of the oil was
studied. To study the influence of multiple, possibly non-
independent parameters on the outcome of the trans-
esterification reaction, the response surface modeling (RSM)
approach was used. For the construction of the model, the
water content and acid value of the oil were changed by adding
water and/or stearic acid to rapeseed oil. The more general
applicability of the model was tested by performing reactions
with other alcohols, other oils and fats, and other fatty acids.
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1. Materials. Different oils and fats were used during the
experiments, and the water content and acid value of these oils and fats
were determined by means of Karl Fischer titration using a Mettler
Toledo V20 Volumetric KF titrator and acid titration using a Mettler
Toledo DL53 titrator equipped with a DG113-SC electrode. The
mono-, di-, and triglyceride contents of the oils and fats were
determined by means of size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) on an
Agilent 1100 series system, using isocratic elution with tetrahydrofuran
(THF) and refractive index detection.
11
The results of these analyses
are shown in Table 1. All oils were used as such, except from the waste
frying oil, which was filtered over a S&S 598
2
white ribbon filter before
use.
The fatty acid profiles of all oils and fats were analyzed by means of
gas chromatography (GC). The results of the GC measurements are
mentioned in Table 2.
Different fatty acids, ranging from C
6
to C
18
and both saturated and
unsaturated, were used to acidify the rapeseed oil. All of them were
purchased from either Merck or Acros. 1-Butanol was obtained from
Received: January 12, 2013
Revised: April 8, 2013
Published: April 8, 2013
Article
pubs.acs.org/EF
© 2013 American Chemical Society 2637 dx.doi.org/10.1021/ef400069x | Energy Fuels 2013, 27, 2637-2642