©2013 Landes Bioscience. Do not distribute.
Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics 9:12, 2558–2565; December 2013; © 2013 Landes Bioscience
2558 Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics Volume 9 Issue 12
COMMENTARY
Plasmodium vivax malaria vaccines
Why are we where we are?
Arturo Reyes-Sandoval
1,
* and Martin F Bachmann
1,2
1
The Jenner Institute; University of Oxford; Oxford, UK;
2
Dermatology; University Hospital Zurich; Zurich, Switzerland
M
alaria is one of the few diseases
in which morbidity is still mea-
sured in hundreds of millions of cases
every year. Plasmodium vivax and Plas-
modium falciparum are responsible for
nearly all the malaria cases in the world
and despite difficulties in obtaining an
exact number, estimates indicate an
astonishing 349–552 million clinical
cases of malaria due to P. falciparum
in 2007 and between 132–391 mil-
lion clinical episodes due to P. vivax in
2009. It is becoming evident that eradi-
cation of malaria will be an arduous
task and P. vivax will be one of the most
difficult species to eliminate and per-
haps become the last standing malaria
parasite. Indeed, in countries that suc-
ceed in decreasing the disease burden,
nearly all the remaining malaria cases
are caused by P. vivax. Such resilience
is mainly due to the sophisticated mech-
anism that the parasite has evolved to
remain dormant for months or years
forming hypnozoites, a small structure
in the liver that will be a major hurdle
in the efforts toward malaria eradica-
tion. Furthermore, while clinical trials
of vaccines against P. falciparum are
making fast progress, a very different
picture is seen with P. vivax, where only
few candidates are currently active in
clinical trials.
Introduction
There is consensus that Plasmodium
vivax is the most widely distributed
human malaria parasite in the world and
the one that presents most challenges in
the route toward malaria elimination.
Almost 3 billion people lived at risk of
P. vivax malaria in 2010. This should not
be surprising if we consider that the para-
site is endemic in a third of the earth’s land
mass, spanning approximately 44 million
square kilometres within 95 countries.
This represents an impressive geographi-
cal range stretching over three continental
zones and including both, hot and tem-
perate climates,
1
an achievement that no
other human malaria parasite has made.
Despite the tremendous disease burden
caused by P. vivax, most efforts in terms
of research and development of preventa-
tive measures have been concentrated in
its sibling, P. falciparum. Figure 1 shows
a comparison of disease burden (Fig. 1A)
and investment in research and global
malaria vaccine pipeline (Fig. 1B) for each
parasite. Disease burden is comparable for
both parasites with a higher proportion of
number of clinical cases caused by P. fal-
ciparum every year,
2,3
a similar proportion
in number of people being at risk and a
more widespread presence of P. vivax in
the world as shown here by the number of
countries where this parasite is endemic.
4,5
The picture changes and a rather uneven
distribution is seen when comparing the
investment on research and the number
of vaccines that are currently reaching
clinical trial status. Between 2007 and
2009, only 3.1% of the global funds were
invested in P. vivax R&D, while 44.6%
was destined to P. falciparum in a study
where 52.3% of funds did not specify a
particular strain.
6
The differences in the
number of clinical trials seem to reflect
the levels of investment for each parasite.
Only two trials for a P. vivax vaccine are
currently active according to WHO and
Keywords: Plasmodium vivax, vaccine,
clinical trials, malaria, human trials
Abbreviations: PEV, pre-erythrocytic
vaccines; BSV, blood-stage vaccines;
TBV, transmission blocking vaccines;
*Correspondence to: Arturo Reyes-Sandoval;
Email: arturo.reyes@ndm.ox.ac.uk
Submitted: 07/23/2013
Accepted: 08/15/2013
http://dx.doi.org/10.4161/hv.2615720