Unicuspid Aortic Valve in Adults: A Systematic Review
Farouk Mookadam, Venkata R. Thota, Ana Maria Garcia-Lopez, Usha R. Emani, Mohsen S.
Alharthi, Jose Zamorano, Bijoy K. Khandheria
Cardiovascular Disease & Internal Medicine, Mayo Clinic Arizona, Scottsdale, Arizona, USA
The natural history of the unicuspid aortic valve
(UAV) is poorly described in the literature, the first
report having been made in 1958 by Edwards (1). It is
unclear whether this anomaly shares any of the char-
acteristics and associations of the more common and
more easily recognized bicuspid aortic valve (BAV), or
if there is an association with other cardiac or extracar-
diac abnormalities. Thus, in an attempt to answer
these questions, a systematic overview was performed
of the medical literature.
The normal aortic valve consists of valve cusps,
sinuses and commissures (2). The most frequent con-
genital malformation of the aortic valve is the presence
of a BAV, with an incidence in the general population
estimated at 0.9-1.4%, and a male:female ratio of 2:1
(3). This anomaly likely has a genetic basis, with epi-
demiological data suggesting a familial pattern in
some cases of left heart obstructive lesions (coarctation
of the aorta, aortic valve stenosis and hypoplastic left
heart syndrome) (4). A BAV is present in more than
50% of the cases with aortic coarctation (5), and in 10-
12% of females with Turner’s syndrome (6). Tissue
abnormalities in patients with BAV are not limited to
the valve, but may involve the ascending aortic media,
with an increased risk of aortic aneurysm and a five- to
nine-fold greater risk of aortic dissection (7).
Developmental abnormalities regarding the number
of valvular cusps other than BAV include unicuspid,
quadricuspid, and pentacuspid aortic valves (8).
Materials and methods
A systematic search, through the Ovid Technologies
(OVID) platform, of the English, Spanish, Portuguese
Address for correspondence:
Farouk Mookadam MD, FRCPC, FACC, MSc (HRM),
Cardiovascular Disease & Internal Medicine, Mayo Clinic Arizona,
13400 E Shea Blvd., Scottsdale, AZ 85259-5499, USA
e-mail: mookadam.farouk@mayo.edu
© Copyright by ICR Publishers 2010
Background and aim of the study: The natural history
of the unicuspid aortic valve (UAV) is poorly
described in the literature. In order to study the asso-
ciation between UAV with any other cardiac or extra
cardiac abnormalities, an evidence-based systematic
review was carried out.
Methods: A computerized search was carried out of
the medical literature published between 1st January
1966 and 1st September 2008 of the following data-
bases: MEDLINE; EMBASE; Web of Science; and the
Cochrane Database.
Results: A total of 231 cases of adult UAV was identi-
fied in 38 articles. The mean patient age was 42 years,
and the most common presenting symptoms report-
ed (in 52 cases) included dyspnea (44%; n = 23), angi-
na (21%; n = 11), and dizziness or syncope (8%; n = 4).
The most common lesion in UAV was isolated aortic
stenosis (AS) (41%; n = 95) and AS with or without
aortic regurgitation (28%; n = 64). The preoperative
diagnosis of UAV is rare, and 139 cases (60%) of UAV
were reported at autopsy or by examination of surgi-
cally excised valves. Aortic valve replacement was
performed in 166 cases (82%). Concomitant aortic
surgery was performed in 47 of the UAV cases (23%),
either for a dilated or aneurysmal aorta.
Conclusion: UAV shares many of the features of
bicuspid aortic valve, including valvular dysfunc-
tion, aortic dilatation, aortic dissection, and dys-
trophic calcification, although these conditions
develop at an earlier age and progress at a faster pace
in UAV. Further investigations are warranted regard-
ing the possibility of a familial incidence, associated
histopathological changes in the aorta, preoperative
diagnostic tools, ideal follow up and surgical inter-
vention.
The Journal of Heart Valve Disease 2010;19:79-85