Regional multimedia distribution of nanomaterials
and associated exposures: A software platform
Haoyang Haven Liu, Muhammad Bilal, Yoram
Cohen
Center for the Environmental Implications of
Nanotechnology
University of California, Los Angeles
Los Angeles, CA, USA
Anastasiya Lazareva, Arturo Keller
Bren School of Environmental Science and Management
University of California, Santa Barbara
Santa Barbara, CA, USA
Abstract— An integrated modeling platform was developed
for assessing the potential release rates of ENMs and their
environmental distribution. ENM release rates are estimated via
life cycle assessment based approach by tracking the target ENM
throughout its life cycle from production to release to the
environment. Potential ENM exposure concentrations and mass
distribution in the various environmental media (i.e., air, water
soil, vegetation) are then evaluated via multimedia modeling that
considers the environment as a collection of compartments linked
by mechanistic intermedia transport processes. A web-based
software implementation of the modeling platform enables rapid
“what-if?” scenario analysis, which can be used to assess the
response of environmental system to various scenarios of ENM
releases, investigate the impact of geographical and
meteorological parameters on ENM distribution in the
environment, compare the impact of ENM production and
potential releases on different regions, we well as estimate source
release rates based on monitored ENM concentrations.
Moreover, the present modeling platform is suitable for research
and teaching regarding environmental multimedia impact
assessment at both the undergraduate and graduate levels. It is
envisioned that the present multimedia analysis platform can
assist regulators, industry, and researchers to rapidly and
critically assess the potential environmental implications of
ENMs and thus ensure that nanotechnology is developed in a
productive and environmentally responsible manner.
Keywords— environmental exposure assessment, life cycle
assessment, engineered nanomaterials, web-based modeling
platform
I. INTRODUCTION
The use of engineered nanomaterials (ENMs) reported in
more than 1000 commercial products has a significant impact
on both natural environmental and human health [1-3]. In order
to ensure responsible and sustainable development of
nanotechnology, it is crucial to assess the environmental
impact of such technology. In recent years, various
environmental impact assessment (EIA) frameworks have been
proposed [4], and these frameworks have recognized the need
to evaluate the potential environmental distributions of ENMs
in addition to their potential toxicological effects. Due to the
scarcity of measured environmental concentration of ENMs, as
well as lack of suitable measurement techniques,
computational modeling approaches have emerged as
promising alternatives from various studies to estimate the
ENM release rates [5, 6] as well as their concentrations in the
environment [7-9].
In order to assess the likely ENMs release rates to the
various environmental compartments, life cycle inventory
assessment (LCIA) based approaches have been utilized to
track the mass of ENM throughout its life cycle from
production, through use, to final disposal and release to the
environment. The above approaches were based on ENM
production rates and a set of transfer coefficients that quantify
the fraction of mass transferred between compartments
(environmental or technical) [5, 10].
Recently, a mechanistic model for assessing the multimedia
environmental distribution of ENMs (MendNano) has been
developed [7] which treats the environment as a collection of
compartments (i.e., media) that are linked via a series of
mechanistically quantified intermedia transport processes, in
order to solve for temporally dynamic concentration and mass
distribution of ENMs in the environment. MendNano was
successfully validated using data for semi-volatile organics,
which have a tendency to adsorb onto ambient particles [11,
12] and thus their transport behaviors are governed by the
particulate phase as is the case with ENMs [7, 13].
Another simple approach based on the SimpleBox [14]
model was recently proposed for nanomaterials
(SimpleBox4nano) [9], which estimates both steady state ENM
environmental mass concentrations as well as temporal
concentration profiles via a first-order kinetics. However, the
environment is dynamic [7] and transport processes do not
necessarily follow a first order kinetic due to episodic
intermedia transport processes such as rain scavenging, which
is known to be able to rapidly remove air-borne pollutants
(particulate or dissolved) to the terrestrial and aquatic surfaces
below [13]. Therefore, assuming first-order kinetics for the
purpose of estimating the temporal concentration profiles may
introduce significant error. It was claimed that
SimpleBox4nano as a compartmental model was an
improvement, attributed to the inclusion of heterogeneous
agglomeration and attachment process via solution of the
Smoluchowski coagulation equation [9]. However, the
attachment efficiency parameter used in the above model was
in fact obtained empirically and assumed to be constant (i.e.,
time invariant). This assumption is not mechanistically correct,
as the attachment efficiency is a function of particle size, which
increases as particles agglomerate. Additionally,
SimpleBox4nano only accounts for the average particle size in
each of the particle classes (freely suspended ENM, ENM
attached to colloids, and ENM attached to larger particles).
2014 IEEE International Conference on Bioinformatics and Biomedicine
978-1-4799-5669-2/14/$31.00 ©2014 IEEE 10