Inflammation & Allergy - Drug Targets, 2009, 8, 321-327 321
1871-5281/09 $55.00+.00 © 2009 Bentham Science Publishers Ltd.
Epidemiological Evidence Associating Secondhand Smoke Exposure with
Cardiovascular Disease
Brent E. Faught
*,1
, Andreas D. Flouris
2
and John Cairney
3
1
Faculty of Applied Health Sciences, Brock University, Canada
2
Institute of Human Performance and Rehabilitation, Centre for Research and Technology Thessaly, Greece
3
Departments of Family Medicine, Psychiatry and Behavioural Neurosciences & Clinical Epidemiology and
Biostatistics, McMaster University, Canada
Abstract: The objective of this paper was to review the epidemiological literature examining the association between
secondhand smoke (SHS) and cardiovascular disease (CVD). Specifically, we examined the various screening methods
available in assessing smoking behaviour and quantifying nicotine absorption. Further, we considered the natural history
of those exposed to SHS and the associated risk of CVD. We reviewed routine methods used to assess exposure to SHS;
evaluated the utility of subjective screening questions regarding smoking behaviour and examined the efficacy of nicotine
and cotinine biomarkers used to quantify SHS exposure in epidemiological and clinical-based research. Self-reporting is
practical and cost-effective in identifying smoking behaviour patterns, but is subject to recall bias and underestimation of
exposure, especially in the presence of children. Nicotine and cotinine biomarkers have proven valuable in quantifying
tobacco smoke absorption and establishing biological plausibility. A combination of SHS self-reported and biomarker
evaluation provide the most stringent method of establishing exposure. Sufficient evidence is reported in epidemiological
research to support a causal association between SHS exposure and increased risks of CVD morbidity and mortality
among both men and women. The risk of developing an acute cardiac syndrome or chronic lifetime coronary events is at
least 30%. Similarly, reduction in the incidence of a myocardial infarction decreases by nearly 50% in the absence of
SHS. Considering the biological plausibility and dose-response relationship between SHS and CVD, effective
interventions that incorporate a comprehensive screening method of behavioral and biological measures of exposure
coupled with efficacious treatment should elicit favorable change for at-risk populations.
Keywords: Secondhand smoke, cardiovascular disease, epidemiology, screening, exposure, biomarkers, self-reporting,
morbidity, mortality.
1. INTRODUCTION
Secondhand smoke (SHS), previously known as passive
smoking is the involuntary breathing of other people's
tobacco smoke, Approximately 5000 chemicals are produced
from cigarette smoke; many poisonous [1]. Secondhand
smoke increases the risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) by
30%, based on epidemiological and biological evidence [2].
A 30-minute SHS exposure was found to affect coronary
flow velocity reserve in non-smokers, suggesting endothelial
dysfunction in coronary circulation [3]. Evidence from
cohort [4, 5], case-control [6] designs and meta-analysis [7]
have all suggested a longitudinal association between CVD
and SHS exposure. Further, clinical-based and animal model
research has supported this association by suggested a
biological plausibility for prolonged exposure to SHS [8-10].
Nevertheless, controversial evidence also exists with regards
to the natural history of SHS exposure and risk of CVD in
non-smokers.
Lack of an accurate method of assessing SHS exposure
has been suggested as a probable reason for the
inconsistency in the literature. Exposure misclassification
appears to be attributed to proxy measures of exposure that
*Address correspondence to this author at the Faculty of Applied Health
Sciences, Brock University, St. Catharines, Ontario, L2S 3A1, Canada;
E-mail: bfaught@brocku.ca
do not account for spousal smoking status [11, 12], exposure
source including home and workplace [5, 11] and lack of
SHS normative data and/or recognition of quantifying
intolerable levels of nicotine differences in pediatric and
adult populations [13]. Valid and efficient means of
objectifying secondhand smoke exposure would lead to more
thorough surveillance techniques of estimating the risk of
cardiovascular disease. This epidemiological review will
address the current literature as it applies to quantifying SHS
exposure and the natural history of cardiovascular disease
among those exposed to secondhand smoke.
2. MEASURING SECONDHAND SMOKE EXPOSURE
Secondhand smoke is a controversial issue in public
health, particularly since laws governing the right to smoke
in community environments are felt to infringe the rights of
those who smoke, while protecting the health of non-
smokers. Public policy is, at times, established based on
epidemiological research. However, observational studies,
the mainstay of most epidemiological research, pose
significant methodological challenges, which in turn often
threaten both the internal and external validity of the results.
Specifically, validity of studies in cardiovascular disease and
SHS is the ability to accurately estimate tobacco smoke
exposure and absorption. Secondhand smoke exposure lacks
a true screening or reference standard and is an area of
research that requires specific attention when interpreting