Delivered by Ingenta to:
Drexel University
IP : 129.25.24.49
Fri, 22 Jun 2007 18:37:15
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Acceleration-Induced Near-Loss of Consciousness:
The “A-LOC” Syndrome
Barry S. Shender, Estrella M. Forster, Leonid Hrebien,
Han Chool Ryoo, and Joseph P. Cammarota, Jr.
SHENDER BS, FORSTER EM, HREBIEN L, RYOO HC, CAMMAROTA JP
JR. Acceleration-induced near-loss of consciousness: the “A-LOC”
syndrome. Aviat Space Environ Med 2003; 74:1021– 8.
Background: There is an insidious phenomenon that can occur when
aircrew are exposed to +Gz stress even at levels that are insufficient to
cause +Gz-induced loss of consciousness (G-LOC). Under these cir-
cumstances aircrew exhibit an altered state of awareness that was
termed Almost Loss of Consciousness (A-LOC) by the U.S. Navy in the
late 1980’s. A-LOC is a syndrome that includes a wide variety of
cognitive, physical, emotional, and physiological symptoms. While A-
LOC has been observed in centrifuge studies and reported in flight for
over 15 yr, a definitive description of the syndrome does not exist.
Methods: Nine subjects were exposed to short +6, 8, and 10 Gz pulses
of increasing duration until they experienced G-LOC. Instrumentation
included two channels of ECG and near infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) to
measure relative cerebral tissue oxygenation (rSO
2
). Subjects indicated
+Gz-induced visual symptoms (light loss, LL) by pressing a switch when
LL began and releasing it when total vision was restored. Short-term
memory loss was assessed using a simple math task. Data analysis
included a description and the time course of the physical, physiologi-
cal, cognitive, and emotional responses. Results: There were 66 epi-
sodes of A-LOC that were identified out of a total of 161 +Gz pulse
exposures. Many incidents of sensory abnormalities, amnesia, confu-
sion, euphoria, difficulty in forming words, and reduced auditory acuity
were documented. Often these responses occurred in multiple subjects
and at different +Gz levels. One of the most common symptoms was a
disconnection between cognition and the ability to act on it. There was
a significant reduction in rSO
2
over baseline, greater overshoot in rSO
2
(increase in oxygenation above baseline after the +Gz exposure), faster
fall in rSO
2
during +Gz stress, and prolonged recovery time associated
with A-LOC as compared with +Gz exposures without symptoms. Con-
clusion: Evaluation of the range of symptoms associated with A-LOC can
lead to a program to increase pilots’ awareness of the phenomenon and
further our understanding of the relationship between the outward
symptoms and the underlying physiological changes.
Keywords: acceleration, A-LOC, loss of consciousness, near infrared
spectroscopy, amnesia, confusion, muscle twitching, N-LOC.
W
HEN AIRCREW of high-performance aircraft are
exposed to acceleration (+Gz) stress, a spec-
trum of symptoms can occur ranging from loss of
peripheral vision (light loss, LL) to blackout to +Gz-
induced loss of consciousness (G-LOC). The mecha-
nisms underlying these events are poorly under-
stood. The focus of +Gz research over the years has
been on the cardiovascular effects of acceleration, i.e.,
a shift of blood supply away from the head to the
extremities. Whinnery (16) proposed a neurologic
mechanism that may be responsible for the contin-
uum of events that lead to G-LOC. He postulated that
G-LOC may not be the result of injury to the central
nervous system, but rather is a protective mechanism
that maximizes the survivability of neurons deprived
of adequate energy supplies. A mathematical model
based on this theory was constructed by Cammarota
(2), and was able to duplicate the loss of conscious-
ness induction time (6.25 s) as measured both by
Rossen et al. (10), after acute arrest of cerebral circu-
lation in man, and by Beckman et al. (1), who studied
G-LOC produced by rapid onset high +Gz pulses.
Beckman et al. found that a high +Gz pulse of only
4.25 s duration was sufficient to cause G-LOC, which
is an apparent contradiction of the acute arrest study.
The model was able to resolve this discrepancy based
on another study conducted by Cammarota et al. (3,4)
duplicating the +Gz profiles used by Beckman et al.,
but with additional measurements, including visual
symptoms, recovery time, cognitive function, and ce-
rebral oxygenation. This study explored the tolerance
of the cephalic nervous system to loss of blood flow,
which upsets the balance between oxygen supply and
demand. Once this balance is disturbed beyond crit-
icality, nothing can prevent the subsequent loss of
consciousness. This was clearly seen by Cammarota
in the incidents of G-LOC that occurred after expo-
sure to a high +Gz pulse was completed and the
centrifuge had returned to a rest plateau.
Even if the stress is insufficient to cause G-LOC,
deficits in motor and cognitive function can still occur.
The intent of this paper is to focus on those events in the
consciousness continuum which may precede G-LOC
but have not been studied in any systematic fashion.
From the Naval Air Systems Command, Patuxent River, MD, (B. S.
Shender, E. M. Forster); Drexel University, Philadelphia, PA (L. Hre-
bien, H.C. Ryoo); EDO M. Tech, Huntingdon Valley, PA (J. P. Cam-
marota, Jr.).
This manuscript was received for review in October 2002. It was
revised in March and May 2003. It was accepted for publication in
May 2003.
Address reprint requests to: Correspondence and address reprint
requests to: Barry S. Shender, Ph.D., who is a Naval Air Systems
Command Fellow, South Engineering Center/Crew Systems Dept.,
NAWCAD, BLDG 2187 SUITE 2280, 48110 Shaw Road UNIT 5, Patux-
ent River, MD 20670-1906; ShenderBS@navair.navy.mil
Reprint & Copyright © by Aerospace Medical Association, Alexan-
dria, VA.
1021 Aviation, Space, and Environmental Medicine • Vol. 74, No. 10 • October 2003