229
Pediatric Exercise Science, 2012, 24, 229-245
© 2012 Human Kinetics, Inc.
Bringolf-Isler, Kriemler, Grize, and Braun-Fahrländer are with the Swiss Tropical and Public Health
Institute and the University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland. Mäder and Ruch are with the Federal Institute
of Sport, Magglingen, Switzerland.
Measuring and Validating Physical Activity
and Sedentary Behavior Comparing
a Parental Questionnaire to Accelermeter
Data and Diaries
Bettina Bringolf-Isler
Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute, University of Basel
Urs Mäder and Nicole Ruch
Federal Institute of Sport
Susi Kriemler, Leticia Grize, and Charlotte Braun-Fahrländer
Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute, University of Basel
Accurately measuring children’s physical activity and their sedentary behavior is
challenging. The present study compared 189 parental responses to a questionnaire
surveying physical activity and sedentary behavior of children aged 6–14 years,
to accelerometer outputs and time activity diaries for the same group. Responses
were analyzed taking age, sex and maternal education into account. Correlation
coeficients between questionnaire reports and accelerometer-based physical
activity across all age groups were acceptable (up to r = .55). Yet, adjustment for
age markedly attenuated these associations, suggesting concomitant inluences
of biological and behavioral processes linked to age. The comparisons of general
time indications in the questionnaire with 24h-diary records suggested that parents
tended to under- and over-report single activities, possibly due to social desirability.
We conclude that physical activity questionnaires need to be designed for speciic
age groups and be administered in combination with objective measurements.
Background
It is widely accepted that regular physical activity is beneicial for children’s health
(22), whereas sedentary behavior is a risk factor for chronic diseases (20,27),
independent of physical activity levels. However, accurately measuring children’s