Water Distribution System Analysis 2010 – WDSA2010, Tucson, AZ, USA, Sept. 12-15, 2010
CHEMICAL STABILITY INCLUSION IN OPTIMIZING THE
OPERATION OF WATER NETWORKS
Avi Ostfeld and Ori Lahav
Faculty of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Technion – Israel Institute of Technology
Haifa 32000, Israel
ostfeld@tx.technion.ac.il, agori@tx.technion.ac.il
Elad Salomons
Director, OptiWater
6 Amikam Israel St., Haifa 34385, Israel
selad@optiwater.com
Abstract
This study is on the inclusion of chemical water stability considerations in optimizing the operation of
water distribution systems. The problem of chemical water instability arises in systems supplied by a
mixture of desalinated, surface, and ground water. Such circumstances are commonly found in countries
which utilize large scale seawater desalination plants within their water supply systems to mitigate water
scarcity problems (e.g., Israel). The most known and problematic occurrence related to unstabilized
water is the phenomenon of "red water" which describes a situation in which a layer of (mostly) iron
oxides is detached from the internal surface of metal pipes into the water, which then reaches the
consumer's taps with a characteristic yellow-brown-red color. Another well known problem is the
deterioration of metal pipes due to slow corrosion. Beyond destroying the pipes, the products of corrosion
consume chlorine products, rendering disinfection less efficient, it creates scales on the pipe’s surface
that increase the energy required for pumping, it supports Biofilm growth and may produce suspensions
of (mainly) iron particles that result in water that is not appealing to the consumer. The developed
methodology in this work links a genetic algorithm, a hydraulic and water quality simulator, and a
numerical scheme for computing the calcium carbonate precipitation potential (CCPP) [which is the
quantitative measure of the precise potential of a solution to precipitate (or dissolve) CaCO3(s)], and the
pH of the water. The model minimizes the cost of pumping and treatment of the water for an operational
time horizon subject to required quantities, pressures, and CCPP and pH constraints. The methodology is
demonstrated on an example application through base runs and sensitivity analysis.
Keywords
chemical water stability, desalination, operation, water distribution systems, optimization, genetic
algorithm
1. INTRODUCTION
The most known and problematic occurrence related to unstabilized water is the phenomenon of "red
water" which describes a situation in which a layer of (mostly) iron oxides is detached from the internal
surface of metal pipes into the water, which then reaches the consumer's taps with a characteristic yellow-
brown-red color. Another well known problem is the deterioration of metal pipes due to slow corrosion.
Beyond destroying the pipes, the products of corrosion consume chlorine products, rendering disinfection
less efficient, it creates scales on the pipe’s surface that increase the energy required for pumping, it
supports biofilm growth and may produce suspensions of (mainly) iron particles that result in water that is
not appealing to the consumer (Sarin et al., 2004).
1206 Water Distribution Systems Analysis 2010 © ASCE 2012
Downloaded 08 Jan 2012 to 132.68.128.37. Redistribution subject to ASCE license or copyright. Visit http://www.ascelibrary.org