Department of Biology, Wingate University, Wingate, NC, USA
Detection of Puccinia pelargonii-zonalis-infected Geranium Tissues and
Urediniospores
Erika A. Scocco
1
, Ronald R. Walcott
2
, Steven N. Jeffers
3
and James W. Buck
1
Authors’ addresses:
1
Department of Plant Pathology, University of Georgia, Griffin, GA, 30223, USA;
2
Department of Plant
Pathology, University of Georgia, Athens, GA, 30602, USA;
3
School of Agricultural, Forest, and Environmental Sciences,
Clemson University, Clemson, SC, 29634, USA (correspondence to J. W. Buck. E-mail: jwbuck@uga.edu)
Received October 30, 2012; accepted December 7, 2012
Keywords: geranium rust, PCR, ornamental
Abstract
The occurrence of geranium rust (caused by Puccinia
pelargonii-zonalis) in commercial greenhouses can
result in unmarketable plants and significant eco-
nomic losses. Currently, detection of geranium rust
relies solely on scouting for symptoms and signs of
the disease. The purpose of this research was to
develop a rapid detection assay for P. pelargonii-
zonalis-infected tissues or urediniospores on green-
house-grown geraniums. Two oligonucleotide primers
were designed based on internal transcribed spacer
sequence data from three isolates of P. pelargonii-
zonalis. The primers amplified a 131-bp product from
genomic DNA from each isolate of P. pelargonii-
zonalis but did not amplify a product from genomic
DNA from twelve other rust fungi or four other
plant pathogenic fungi. A PCR product was amplified
consistently from solutions that contained 1 ng or
100 pg/ml of purified P. pelargonii-zonalis DNA in
conventional PCR and at 1 pg/ml using real-time
PCR. The detection threshold was 10
2
urediniospores/
ml for real-time PCR and 10
4
urediniospores/ml for
conventional PCR using urediniospores collected by
vacuum from sporulating lesions. Puccinia pelargonii-
zonalis DNA was amplified by real-time PCR from
urediniospores washed from a single inoculated leaf,
but recovered urediniospores were below detection
threshold from one inoculated leaf with 5, 10, 25 and
50 non-inoculated leaves. Conventional and real-time
PCR did not detect P. pelargonii-zonalis in infected
leaf tissues, presumably due to PCR inhibitors in the
geranium leaf tissue. The inhibition of both conven-
tional and real-time PCR by geranium tissues suggests
that a detection assay focusing on urediniospore
recovery and microscopic examination with subse-
quent species verification by PCR may be the most
efficient method for assessing the presence of
geranium rust in greenhouses.
Introduction
The US floriculture industry, including bedding and
garden plants, potted herbaceous perennials, flowering
and foliage plants and cut flowers, was valued at US
$4.08 billion in 2010 (USA Department of Agriculture
National Agriculture Statistics Service 2012). Vegeta-
tive zonal geranium (Pelargonium 9hortorum) cuttings
used to produce bedding plants sold as flats or hanging
baskets were valued at US $29 million in a 15-state
survey of US growers (USA Department of Agriculture
National Agriculture Statistics Service 2012). The pres-
ence of geranium rust, caused by Puccinia pelargonii-
zonalis, in commercial greenhouses can result in
unmarketable plants and major economic losses (Jeffers
1998; Buck 2007).
The first report of geranium rust in the United States
occurred in 1967 in New York followed by occurrences
in other states during the 1970s (Dimock et al. 1968;
Wehlburg 1970; Nichols and Forer 1972). Currently,
P. pelargonii-zonalis is endemic in California and is con-
sidered a quarantine pathogen in Ohio (Ohio Depart-
ment of Agriculture 2010). Consequently, any zonal
geranium plant material shipped from California to
Ohio must be certified disease free. Occasional geranium
rust outbreaks have also occurred in the southeastern
United States (Jeffers 1998). Accidental introductions of
exotic fungal pathogens, including Puccinia horiana
(chrysanthemum white rust) and Uromyces transversalis
(gladiolus rust), are of major concern to growers of
ornamental plants in the United States (Wise et al.
2004; Rossman 2009). Mandatory federal quarantine
and eradication measures to eliminate these fungi are
expensive and occasionally fail (Wise et al. 2004). This
was the case with daylily rust in the United States, where
a federal quarantine eventually failed due to rapid and
widespread movement of infected plants that resulted in
establishment of the disease over a large geographical
area (Wise et al. 2004; Buck and Ono 2012).
J Phytopathol 161:341–347 (2013) doi: 10.1111/jph.12072
© 2013 Blackwell Verlag GmbH