23
The American Archivist Vol. 77, No. 1 Spring/Summer 2014 23–63
The Strange Career of Jim Crow
Archives: Race, Space, and
History in the Mid-Twentieth-
Century American South
Alex H. Poole
ABSTRACT
Jim Crow practices touched every aspect of southern life in the middle of the twen-
tieth century. As surviving documentary evidence attests, archives and archivists in
the South, particularly in the University of North Carolina system, were deeply impli-
cated in upholding segregation. This article probes that dynamic relationship, stress-
ing the courage of those African American scholars who challenged Jim Crow on
quotidian and organizational bases. The history of segregation in archival reposito-
ries illuminates four themes. First, it underlines the agency and power wielded by
archival professionals; the archives is never a neutral space. Second, it suggests how
archival professionals conducted—or failed to conduct—outreach to attract users and
to promote use. In this way they betrayed their professional mission by providing
lesser forms of access and service to African Americans. Third, the story of Jim Crow
archives shows the need for archivists to be held accountable in their record-collect-
ing and recordkeeping practices; it also demonstrates the central importance of
diversity in the profession, in the types of records retained, and in their content.
Finally, it indicates the necessity of ensuring that a representative documentary trail
remains for historians. In short, archivists affect the writing of history as much in
the 2010s as they did in the 1950s. The legacy of Jim Crow’s “strange career” in the
archives represents a valuable lesson for archival professionals in their pursuit of
social justice.
THEODORE CALVIN PEASE AWARD
© Alex H. Poole.
KEY WORDS
Segregation, Social Justice, Race, Space, Historiography, Accountability, Diversity