National narcissism: Internal dimensions and international correlates
Huajian Cai
1
and Peter Gries
2
1
Key Laboratory of Behavior Science, Institute of Psychology, Chinese Academy of Sciences,
Beijing, China,
2
Institute for US–China Issues, University of Oklahoma, Norman, Oklahoma, USA
Abstract: In studies conducted in the United States and China, we explored the impact of national narcissism, grandiosity, and entitlement,
demonstrating that: (a) national narcissism was distinct from both individual narcissism and collective self-esteem (patriotism); (b) national
entitlement and national grandiosity constituted two distinct dimensions of national narcissism; and (c) national narcissism, national
grandiosity, and national entitlement, but not individual narcissism, were uniquely predictive of political attitudes, foreign policy prefer-
ences, and purchase intentions. Together, these findings provided convergent evidence for the utility of national narcissism and its two
internal dimensions, national entitlement and national grandiosity.
Keywords: entitlement; grandiosity; narcissism; national narcissism; U.S.–China relations
Correspondence: Dr. Huajian Cai, Department of Psychology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, 16 Lincui Road, Chaoyang District,
Beijing 100101, China. Email: huajian.cai@gmail.com
Received 15 June 2012. Accepted 17 December 2012.
Twenge and Campbell (2009) have argued that a “narcissism
epidemic” afflictsAmerica today. “American culture’s focus
on self-admiration has caused a flight from reality to the land
of grandiose fantasy,” they write, “All this fantasy might feel
good, but . . . inflated desires eventually crash to earth” (p.
4). Although few disagree about the harmful consequences
of narcissism, whether or not a narcissism epidemic actually
exists in America today has become a subject of hot debate
among psychologists (see Donnellan, Trzesniewski, &
Robins, 2009; Trzesniewski, Donnellan, & Robins, 2008;
Twenge & Foster, 2008, 2010; Twenge, Konrath, Foster,
Campbell, & Bushman, 2008).
Given the recent scholarly and popular attention paid to
narcissistic attachment to the self and its negative conse-
quences for interpersonal relations, it is perhaps surprising
that little attention has been given to the possibility of
narcissistic identification with the nation and its possible
negative consequences for international relations. Expand-
ing on two extant but separate streams of scholarship on
narcissism, this paper develops the construct of “national
narcissism.”
In one line of research, de Zavala, Cichocka, Eidelson,
and Jayawickreme (2009) have suggested that narcissism at
the individual level can be conceptually extended to inter-
group relations. They proposed the concept of “collective
narcissism,” defined as an emotional investment in “an
inflated image of an ingroup” (p. 1074). They developed a
nine-item Collective Narcissism (CN) Scale, adapting indi-
vidual level narcissism items by replacing “I” with “my
group,” such as “My group deserves special treatment.” They
found that their CN Scale correlated with a number of per-
ceptual and behavioral measures, such as threat perception
and support for aggressive action, concluding that “Collec-
tive narcissism is related to intergroup aggressiveness
because it increases sensitivity to signs of criticism or unfair
treatment in an intergroup context” (p. 1091). Their research
included a case study of national collective narcissism.
However, because the focus of their research was on collec-
tive narcissism in general, when de Zavala et al. sought to
operationalize collective narcissism as, for example, a Pole,
they did so indirectly, priming the participants’ national
identity as a Pole only in the instructions before they com-
pleted the CN Scale containing the “my group” items. As a
specific and important case of collective narcissism, we
believe that a more direct measure and examination of
national narcissism is warranted.
PsyCh Journal 2 (2013): 122–132
DOI: 10.1002/pchj.26
© 2013 The Institute of Psychology, Chinese Academy of Sciences and Wiley Publishing Asia Pty Ltd