Abstract— Previous studies have shown that the motor training
in a virtual-environment with the augmented feedback promotes
motor learning in normal subjects and in long-term post-stroke
patients. We evaluated whether this approach could be useful
also for treating patients with arm motor deficits due to a recent
stroke. Thirty-eight patients were included in the study within 3
months from an ischemic stroke in the territory of the middle
cerebral artery. Twenty-five subjects received training with the
Reinforced Feedback in Virtual Environment (RFVE) therapy
for the arm, and thirteen patients received an equal amount of a
conventional rehabilitation (CR) therapy focused to the upper
limb. Before and after therapy, the autonomy of daily living
activities were assessed with the Functional Independence
Measure (FIM) and the degree of motor impairment was
measured with the Fugl-Meyer scale for the upper extremity
(FM-UE). The RFVE therapy group showed significant
improvements in the FM-UE and the FIM scale mean scores.
The conventional therapy determined smaller and not
statistically significant scores improvements. These data indicate
that the recovery of arm motor function in patients after a
recent stroke appear to be speeded up by an augmented
feedback provided in a virtual-environment.
I. INTRODUCTION
REVIOUS evidence on healthy subjects has
demonstrated that appropriate feedback on the nature of
the movement (knowledge of performance) and some
variables of outcome (knowledge of results) may help to
temporarily or permanently improve motor performance [1]
– [6]. In this regard, computer-based systems can provide
subjects with artificially-enhanced feedback that may
facilitate the acquisition of new motor skills. Todorov and
co-workers reported that training in virtual environments
Manuscript received April 23, 2007.
L. Piron is with the IRCCS San Camillo Hospital, via Alberoni 70,
30126 Lido di Venezia, Venezia, Italy (+39 041 2207214; fax: +39 041
731330; e-mail: lab.neuroscienze@ospedalesancamillo.net ).
P. Tombolini as Ordinary Associate of A.I.FI. (Associazione Italiana
Fisioterapisti)) (e-mail: ptombolini@libero.it ).
A. Turolla is with the IRCCS San Camillo Hospital, via Alberoni 70,
30126 Lido di Venezia, Venezia, Italy (e-mail: andreaturolla@tin.it ).
C. Zucconi is with the IRCCS San Camillo Hospital, via Alberoni 70,
30126 Lido di Venezia, Venezia, Italy (e-mail: silvazu@hotmail.com ).
M. Agostini is with the IRCCS San Camillo Hospital, via Alberoni 70,
30126 Lido di Venezia, Venezia, Italy (e-mail: miki.ago@libero.it ).
M. Dam is with the Dept. of Neurology and Psychiatry, University of
Padova, via Giustiniani 5, 35218 Padova, Italy (mauro.dam@unipd.it ).
G. Santarello is with the IRCCS San Camillo Hospital, via Alberoni 70,
30126 Lido di Venezia, Italy (e-mail: giosantarello@hotmail.com ).
F. Piccione is with the IRCCS San Camillo Hospital, via Alberoni 70,
30126 Lido di Venezia, Italy (e-mail: piccioneparinello@aliceposta.it ).
P. Tonin is with the IRCCS San Camillo Hospital, via Alberoni 70,
30126 Lido di Venezia, Venezia, Italy (e-mail: patonin@tin.it ).
with enhanced feedback promotes the learning of complex
multi-join motor task, better than conventional methods [7].
Preliminary reports have indicated that a virtual-reality
based therapy improves upper-limb motor performance in
the chronic phase after stroke [8] – [11]. Along this line, we
evaluated whether this approach could be useful also for
treating patients with arm motor deficits due to a recent
stroke.
II. METHODS
Thirty-eight patients were included in the study; they were
suffering from mild/intermediate arm motor impairments
due to an ischemic stroke, occurring within three months
before the study.
All patients presented a mild to intermediate arm
impairment. The demographic characteristics of the 38
patients are summarized in Table I.
TABLE I
GROUPS’ DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS
All patients
(n.=38)
RFVE Group
Age, years ± SD
Sex, M/F
Stroke to rehabilitation interval,
months ± SD
61.5 ± 9.4
17/8
2.5 ± 1.5
Control Group
Age, years ± SD
Sex, M/F
Stroke to rehabilitation interval,
months ± SD
61.2 ± 6.6
8/5
2.6 ± 1.6
Twenty-five subjects (RFVE Group) received Reinforced
Feedback in Virtual Environment (RFVE) therapy for the
arm, and thirteen patients (Control Group) received an equal
amount of a conventional rehabilitation (CR) therapy
focused to the upper limb.
Before and after therapy, the autonomy of daily living
activities were assessed with the Functional Independence
Measure (FIM) and the degree of motor impairment was
measured with the Fugl-Meyer scale for the upper extremity
(FM-UE). For both groups the therapy lasted from 5 to 7
weeks, 1 hour daily for five days a week.
The equipment used for the RFVE therapy consisted of a
PC workstation, a high-resolution LCD projector, a 3D
motion-capture system (Polhemus 3Space Fastrack,
Vermont, U.S.A.), and a dedicated software, developed at
Massachusetts Institute of Technology U.S.A., for
processing data and creating the virtual environment.
Reinforced Feedback in Virtual Environment Facilitates the Arm
Motor Recovery in Patients after a Recent Stroke
Lamberto Piron, Paolo Tombolini, Andrea Turolla, Carla Zucconi, Michela Agostini, Mauro Dam,
Giovanna Santarello, Francesco Piccione and Paolo Tonin
P
121 1-4244-1204-8/07/$25.00 ©2007 IEEE