Implementation of routine biochemical validation
and an ‘opt out’ referral pathway for smoking
cessation in pregnancy
Linda Bauld
1,5
, Lucy Hackshaw
2
, Janet Ferguson
1,5
, Tim Coleman
3,5
, Gordon Taylor
4
&
Ruth Salway
4
School of Management, University of Stirling, Stirling, UK,
1
The Institute of Work Health and Organisations, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK,
2
Divison of Primary Care, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK,
3
Department for Health, University of Bath, Bath, UK
4
and UK Centre forTobacco Control
Studies, UK
5
ABSTRACT
Aims To introduce an ‘opt out’ referral pathway for smoking cessation in pregnancy and to compare different
methods for identifying pregnant smokers in maternity care. Design Pilot study that analysed routine data from
maternity and smoking cessation services with biochemical validation of smoking status. Setting Dudley and South
Birmingham, England. Participants A total of 3712 women who entered the referral pathway—1498 in Dudley and
2214 in South Birmingham. Measurements Routine monitoring data on smoking at maternity booking, referral to
smoking cessation services, number of women who set quit dates set and short-term (4-week) self-report smoking
status. Comparison of self-report, carbon monoxide (CO)-validated and urinary cotinine-validated smoking status for
a subsample (n = 1492) of women at maternity booking. Findings In Dudley 27% of women who entered the opt out
referral pathway were identified as smokers following CO testing. Of those referred to the smoking cessation services,
19% reported stopping smoking at 4-week follow-up. In South Birmingham 17% were smokers at booking, with 5% of
those referred recorded as non-smokers at 4 weeks. The number of women quitting did not increase during the study
when compared with the previous year, despite higher referral rates in both areas. An optimum cut-off CO measure-
ment of 4 parts per million (p.p.m.) was identified for sensitivity and specificity. Conclusion The introduction of an
opt out referral pathway between maternity and stop smoking services resulted in more women being referred for
support to quit but not higher numbers of quitters, suggesting that automatic referral may include women who are not
motivated to stop and who may not engage with services. Routine carbon monoxide monitoring introduced as part of
a referral pathway should involve a cut-off of 4p.p.m. to identify smoking in pregnancy.
Keywords Carbon monoxide, cotinine, pilot, pregnancy, referral, smoking cessation.
Correspondence to: Professor Linda Bauld, School of Management, University of Stirling, Stirling FK9 4LA, UK. E-mail: Linda.Bauld@stir.ac.uk
Submitted 18 March 2012; initial review completed 4 April 2012; final version accepted 28 August 2012
INTRODUCTION
Reducing smoking in pregnancy is a health policy prior-
ity in the United Kingdom, as in many other developed
countries [1]. Maternal smoking in pregnancy causes
substantial harm, increasing the risk of miscarriage, still-
birth, prematurity, low birth weight, perinatal morbidity
and mortality, neonatal or sudden infant death, asthma
[2–5], attention deficit hyperactive disorder, learning
difficulties [6], obesity and diabetes [7].
While many women in the United Kingdom stop
smoking before becoming pregnant or soon after, one in
four women smoke for part of pregnancy and one in eight
smoke throughout [8]. Compared to women in advan-
taged circumstances, women in disadvantaged circum-
stances are four times more likely to smoke prior to
pregnancy and are half as likely to quit in pregnancy;
disadvantaged women are also more likely to resume
smoking after birth [9].
However, there are interventions known to be effective
in promoting cessation in pregnancy. The most recent
Cochrane Review of smoking cessation interventions
pooled results from 72 trials and concluded that cessation
interventions in early pregnancy can reduce smoking in
RESEARCH REPORT
doi:10.1111/j.1360-0443.2012.04086.x
© 2012 The Authors, Addiction © 2012 Society for the Study of Addiction Addiction, 107 (Suppl. 2), 53–60