COMMUNICATION www.rsc.org/dalton | Dalton Transactions
Extension of the charge separated-state lifetime by supramolecular
association of a tetrathiafulvalene electron donor to a zinc/gold bisporphyrin†
Julien Boixel,
a
J´ erˆ ome Fortage,
a
Errol Blart,
a
Yann Pellegrin,
a
Leif Hammarstr ¨ om,*
b
Hans-Christian Becker*
b
and Fabrice Odobel*
a
Received 2nd July 2009, Accepted 10th November 2009
First published as an Advance Article on the web 27th November 2009
DOI: 10.1039/b920079g
Supramolecular triads were prepared by self-assembly of
4¢-pyridyl-2-tetrathiafulvalene axially bound on ZnP-spacer-
AuP
+
dyads; the lifetime of the charge separated state (
+
TTF-
ZnP-Spacer-AuP
∑
) formed upon light excitation of the triad
is greatly increased with respect to that found in the parent
dyad.
Non-covalently bonded supramolecular assemblies for photoin-
duced charge separation have drawn considerable attention be-
cause their preparations are relatively more accessible and offer
higher versatility than those of fully covalent arrays. Besides,
this approach can be seen as a direct inspiration of the natural
photosynthetic reaction center because the active components
in the biological system are assembled via non-covalent bonds.
Self-assembly involving the preferred pentacoordination of zinc
porphyrins (ZnPs) with axial amine ligands is a well-known
strategy to construct sophisticated architectures for light harvest-
ing properties.
1
The same approach was also used to assemble
an electron acceptor, such as fullerene and naphthalene or
perylene diimide onto a ZnP for photoinduced electron transfer.
2-4
Strangely, the implementation of this strategy with an electron
donor on a zinc porphyrin-spacer-electron acceptor dyad (ZnP-S-
A) has never been explored, in spite of its potential utility. Indeed,
in the literature there are many covalent assemblies involving
a ZnP
5
that could be revisited with this strategy in order to
extend the charge separated state lifetime. In this work we have
used the 4¢-pyridyl-2-tetrathiafulvalene (abbreviated hereafter p-
TTF) as a secondary electron donor with the heterometallic
porphyrin dyads shown in Fig. 1. Recently, we reported on the
photophysical properties of these zinc porphyrin-gold porphyrin
dyads linked either with an oligophenylene ethynylene (ZnP-OPE-
AuP
+
)
6a
or a bisethynyl quaterthiophene (ZnP-quater-AuP
+
)
6b
spacer. Excitation of the zinc porphyrin induces a very fast and
quantitative electron transfer to the adjacent gold porphyrin
leading to a charge separated state lifetime of 2.2 ns and 3.1 ns
respectively in ZnP-OPE-AuP
+
(in dichloromethane) and ZnP-
quater-AuP
+
(in toluene). In this work, we show that the ligand
a
CEISAM, Chimie Et Interdisciplinarit´ e, Synth` ese, Analyse, Mod´ elisation,
CNRS, UMR CNRS 6230, UFR des Sciences et des Techniques 2, rue de la
Houssini` ere - BP 92208, 44322 NANTES Cedex 3, France. E-mail: Fabrice.
Odobel@univ-nantes.fr
b
Chemical Physics, Department of Photochemistry and Molecular Sci-
ence, Uppsala University, Box 523, SE-751 20 Uppsala, Sweden. E-mail:
Leif@fotomol.uu.se
†Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Synthetic proce-
dures for the preparation of p-TTF, electrochemistry, spectroelectrochem-
istry and transient absorption spectra. See DOI: 10.1039/b920079g
Fig. 1 Structures of the compounds described in this study.
p-TTF effectively binds to the zinc porphyrin of these dyads
and substantially increases the charge separated state lifetime;
10 times for ZnP-quater-AuP
+
and 50 times for ZnP-OPE-
AuP
+
. The synthesis of the new ligand p-TTF is based on
a Stille cross-coupling reaction between 4-bromopyridine and
(tetrabutylstannyl)tetrathiafulvalene as described in the ESI.†
Cyclic voltammetry indicated that the first oxidation potential of
p-TTF occurs at 0.18 V vs. SCE in dichloromethane (Fig. S1,
ESI†). Under the same conditions, the oxidation potential of
the zinc porphyrin in the dyads is 0.76 V, therefore there is
approximately a 0.58 eV driving force
7
for the hole shift reaction
for the oxidized zinc porphyrin to the TTF. The characteristic
absorption spectrum of the radical cation of p-TTF was recorded
by spectroelectrochemistry (Fig. S2, ESI†) showing bands at 445
and 600 nm.
The association constants (K
a
) between p-TTF and the zinc
porphyrin in the corresponding ZnP-OPE-TIPS or ZnP-quater-
TIPS reference compounds were measured by UV-Vis absorption
titration. The anticipated red-shift and intensification of the
Q-bands of ZnP could be clearly observed upon addition of
increasing amounts of p-TTF in a solution of the dyad, thus
evidencing the effective coordination of the pyridine onto the zinc
porphyrin (Fig. S3, ESI†). Fitting the experimental data to the
Scatchard equation n/L = nK
a
- nK
a
where n is the concentration
of bound ligands over total concentration of ZnP binding sites,
n is the number of binding sites per ZnP (assumed to be 1 in the
evaluation of the spectra), L is the concentration of free ligand,
and K
a
is the binding constant.
8
This led to K
a
= 1.0 ¥ 10
4
M
-1
for p-TTF ◊◊◊ ZnP-OPE-TIPS in dichloromethane, and slightly
1450 | Dalton Trans., 2010, 39, 1450–1452 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2010