Compressibility behaviour of remoulded, fine-
grained soils and correlation with index properties
A. Sridharan and H.B. Nagaraj
Abstract: Correlating engineering properties with index properties has assumed greater significance in the recent past
in the field of geotechnical engineering. Although attempts have been made in the past to correlate compressibility
with various index properties individually, all the properties affecting compressibility behaviour have not been consid-
ered together in any single study to examine which index property of the soil correlates best with compressibility
behaviour, especially within a set of test results. In the present study, 10 soils covering a sufficiently wide range of
liquid limit, plastic limit, and shrinkage limit were selected and conventional consolidation tests were carried out
starting with their initial water contents almost equal to their respective liquid limits. The compressibility behaviour is
vastly different for pairs of soils having nearly the same liquid limit, but different plasticity characteristics. The
relationship between void ratio and consolidation pressure is more closely related to the shrinkage index (shrinkage
index = liquid limit – shrinkage limit) than to the plasticity index. Wide variations are seen with the liquid limit. For
the soils investigated, the compression index relates better with the shrinkage index than with the plasticity index or
liquid limit.
Key words: Atterberg limits, classification, clays, compressibility, laboratory tests.
Résumé : La corrélation des propriétés pour fin de conception avec les propriétés d’indices a pris une signification
accrue récemment dans le domaine de la géotechnique. Alors que des tentatives ont été faites dans le passé pour
corréler la compressibilité avec différents indices pris individuellement, on n’a jamais considéré globalement toutes
les propriétés dans une étude donnée pour examiner quelle propriété d’indice présente la meilleure corrélation avec le
comportement en compressibilité particulièrement à l’intérieur d’un ensemble de résultats d’essais. Dans la présente
étude, dix sols couvrant une plage suffisamment large de limites de liquidité, de plasticité et de gonflement ont été
sélectionnés, et des essais de consolidation conventionnels ont été réalisés en partant de leurs teneurs en eau initiales
quasiment égales à leurs limites de liquidité respectives. On trouve que le comportement en compressibilité est
extrêmement différent pour des paires de sols ayant quasiment la même limite de liquidité, mais différentes
caractéristiques de plasticité. On trouve que les courbes d’indice de vide-pression suivent mieux l’indice de
gonflement (indice de gonflement = limite de liquidité – limite de gonflement) que l’indice de plasticité. De grandes
variations ont été observées avec la limite de liquidité. On voit que pour les sols étudiés, l’indice de compression
offre une meilleure corrélation avec l’indice de gonflement qu’avec l’indice de plasticité ou la limite de liquidité.
Mots clés : limites d’Atterberg, classification, argiles, compressibilité, essais de laboratoire.
[Traduit par la Rédaction] Notes 722
Introduction
Compressibility of soils is an important engineering con-
sideration. The oedometer test is used to determine the com-
pressibility characteristics of soils which are typically
described using the compression index, C
c
, and the coeffi-
cient of consolidation, c
v
. The compression index is used to
predict how much settlement will take place, and the coeffi-
cient of consolidation is a rate parameter used to predict how
long it will take for a given amount of compression to take
place. However, oedometer testing requires undisturbed sam-
ples and is quite time-consuming and expensive. For this
reason, researchers in the past have correlated compressibil-
ity characteristics with index properties. The first well-known
correlation was presented by Skempton (1944), who gave
the following correlation for the compressibility of
remoulded soils with liquid limit, w
L
:
[1] C
c
= 0.007(w
L
– 10)
Other subsequent correlations are presented in Table 1,
which shows that different researchers have used various
parameters, including liquid limit (w
L
), natural moisture
content (w
n
), initial in situ void ratio (e
o
), dry unit weight
(γ
d
), plasticity index (I
P
), and void ratio at liquid limit (e
L
).
The availability of so many equations suggests that none are
completely satisfactory to generalize and correlate com-
pressibility with the index or other properties.
Nagaraj and Srinivasa Murthy (1983) extended Skempton’s
compressibility equation (eq. [1]) using the void ratio at liq-
uid limit (e
L
) to give a generalized equation for compressibility
Can. Geotech. J. 37: 712–722 (2000) © 2000 NRC Canada
712
Received May 3, 1999. Accepted October 7, 1999.
A. Sridharan. Department of Civil Engineering, Indian
Institute of Science, Bangalore 560 012, India.
H.B. Nagaraj. Department of Civil Engineering, BMS
College of Engineering, Bangalore 560 019, India.