Abusive Supervision and Contextual Performance:
The Mediating Role of Emotional Exhaustion and
the Moderating Role of Work Unit Structure
Samuel Aryee
1
, Li-Yun Sun
2
, Zhen Xiong George Chen
3
and Yaw A. Debrah
4
1
Aston University, UK,
2
Macau University of Science and Technology, China,
3
The Australian
National University, Australia, and
4
Swansea University, UK
ABSTRACT This study examined the processes linking abusive supervision to employee
contextual performance by focusing on the mediating influence of emotional exhaustion
and the moderating influence of work unit structure. Data were obtained from 285
subordinate–supervisor dyads from three manufacturing companies in north-eastern
China. The results revealed that: (i) emotional exhaustion mediated the relationships
between abusive supervision and the contextual performance dimensions of
interpersonal facilitation and job dedication; and (ii) work unit structure moderated these
relationships such that the relationships were stronger in mechanistic than in organic
work unit structures.
KEYWORDS abusive supervision, contextual performance, emotional exhaustion, work
unit structure
I dread each day coming to work. Once inside the door, I feel ‘chained’ to my
desk like a prisoner. My boss is the ‘prison warden’ who delights in ‘torturing’ me
with a daily barrage of public criticism and ridicule. I feel so powerless, like a
‘pawn’ being played in one of his power games. My friends ask . . . Why do I stay
and take this abuse?
– Manager cited in Bies and Tripp (1998, p. 203)
INTRODUCTION
Recent scholarly efforts to understand the dark side of organizational life have
focused on dysfunctional or deviant workplace behaviours (Andersson & Pearson,
1999; Ashforth, 1994; Bennett & Robinson, 2000; Duffy, Ganster, & Pagon,
2002; Keashly, Trott, & MacLean, 1994). Tierney and Tepper (2007, p. 171)
observed that although ‘the preponderance of leadership research has focused on
Management and Organization Review 4:3 393–411
doi: 10.1111/j.1740-8784.2008.00118.x
© 2008 The Authors
Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd