A method for calculating soil pressure overlying human burials
Glenys McGowan, Jonathan Prangnell
*
School of Social Science, The University of Queensland, Queensland 4072, Australia
article info
Article history:
Received 13 May 2014
Received in revised form
15 September 2014
Accepted 17 September 2014
Available online 6 October 2014
Keywords:
Soil
Weight
Vertical load
Taphonomy
Burial
Exhumation
Cemetery
abstract
While damage to the human skeleton due to vertical pressure exerted by overlying soil is a common
observation at archaeological excavations, comparatively few studies have attempted to quantify the
magnitude of this pressure. As part of a suite of taphonomic studies of a nineteenth-century cemetery
located in Brisbane, Australia, a soil loading calculation equation usually employed in civil engineering is
used to calculate soil vertical pressure at various depths for both child and adult graves. This cemetery
was characterised by extreme vertical compression of coffin burials to the extent that human remains
were sandwiched between the coffin base and lid to a thickness of just a few centimetres. Calculations
determined that, because of their narrower grave shafts, the burials of children experienced between 40%
(1.83 m depth) and 27% (0.91 m depth) less vertical soil pressure than those of adults buried at similar
depths. Further calculations for different soil types showed that coarser grained soils such as gravel and
sand exerted less vertical pressure than a similar volume of saturated clay due to the amount of air
trapped between the coarser grains. It is anticipated that the equation utilised in this study could find
widespread applications in the fields of archaeology, physical anthropology, forensic archaeology and
cultural heritage management.
© 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The potential for vertical soil pressure to contribute to bone
degradation was highlighted during a salvage excavation con-
ducted at the North Brisbane Burial Ground (NBBG), a nineteenth-
century cemetery in the centre of Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.
Many of the burials had suffered damage due to extreme vertical
compression (Fig. 1). In the majority of these the wooden coffin lid
had fallen in and been pressed against the human remains and the
coffin base. The sides of the coffins were deformed in response to
soil movements, and had lost some of their vertical height, but still
remained relatively upright (Fig. 2). Three wooden coffins with lead
liners were generally more resistant to compression, with the sides
showing inward buckling in response to vertical pressure (Fig. 3).
It is estimated that the NBBG received approximately 5000 in-
terments between 1843 and 1875, in separate cemeteries according
to religious denomination (Rains and Prangnell, 2002). The ceme-
teries were each located on dissected slopes of clay developed over
phyllite bedrock (McGowan, 2008:197). Generally, bodies were
buried in hexagonal wooden coffins covered inside and out with
textiles (Prangnell and McGowan, 2013). There is contemporary
documentary evidence that some burials were interred at quite
shallow depths. In 1875, the Brisbane Courier (5/3/1875:2) reported
that children's and adults' graves in the Anglican cemetery were
only being dug to a depth of 3 ft (0.91 m), apparently upon in-
structions from the Trustees. After its closure, the Burial Ground
became overgrown and neglected for a period of 36 years, before
being redeveloped into parkland (Prangnell and McGowan, 2013).
Low-lying parts were used as a municipal landfill and nightsoil
disposal site from 1914 until the early 1960s (Prangnell and
McGowan, 2009).
Earlier this century, the building of a new sports stadium on the
site necessitated the excavation of 397 burials discovered during
the preparation of foundations and service trenches (McGowan and
Prangnell, 2011). Human remains, coffin wood, textiles and metal
artefacts were found to be in a surprisingly poor state of preser-
vation after only 160 years of burial, a comparatively brief time
span by archaeological standards. By the time of excavation, 6% of
coffin wood, 77% of textiles and 22% of metal coffin furniture had
completely disappeared from the archaeological record (McGowan,
2008:364). Of the 397 burials excavated 54.2% contained only soil
silhouettes, 29.9% contained highly compressed and powdered
skeletons, 12.3% contained compressed and fragmented bones
(Fig. 1), 3.4% had broken bones in anatomical position and one
burial was well preserved with a complete but disarticulated
skeleton (Fig. 3).
* Corresponding author. Tel.: þ61 733652887.
E-mail addresses: g.mcgowan@uq.edu.au (G. McGowan), j.prangnell@uq.edu.au
(J. Prangnell).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Archaeological Science
journal homepage: http://www.elsevier.com/locate/jas
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2014.09.016
0305-4403/© 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Journal of Archaeological Science 53 (2015) 12e18