Dynamic energy performance analysis: Case study for energy
efficiency retrofits of hospital buildings
Annamaria Buonomano
a
, Francesco Calise
a, *
, Gabriele Ferruzzi
b
, Adolfo Palombo
a
a
DII, Univ. of Naples Federico II, P.le Tecchio 80, 80125 Naples, Italy
b
DI, Univ. of Naples Parthenope, Centro Direz. IS.C4, 80143 Naples, Italy
article info
Article history:
Received 17 June 2014
Received in revised form
29 September 2014
Accepted 15 October 2014
Available online 7 November 2014
Keywords:
Hospital buildings
Energy refurbishment of buildings
Energy audit
Dynamic energy performance simulation
abstract
This paper investigates several actions for the energy refurbishment of some buildings of the University
Hospital Federico II of Naples. The analysis focuses on a specific lot of 4 buildings, representative of the
whole district hospital. For those structures, sustainable energy savings actions are investigated. They
regard the installation of: i) roofs thermal insulation; ii) a substation climatic 3-way valve; iii) radiators
thermostatic valves; iv) AHU (air handling unit) time-programmable regulation. This paper aims at
presenting an investigation methodology, useful for designers and other stakeholders involved in hos-
pital energy refurbishments, based on an integrated approach which combines dynamic energy per-
formance simulations and experimental campaigns. In order to measure all the simulations' missing
input parameters, a suitable experimental analysis, including measurements of temperature, humidity,
flow rate and density of construction materials, is performed. A thermographic investigation is also
performed for investigating the building envelope performance. This analysis showed that significant
savings can be achieved especially by adopting radiators thermostatic valves and AHU regulations.
Coherently, the installation of a 3-way valve in the substation does not determine significant additional
savings when radiators thermostatic valves are already installed. For high-rise buildings, roofs insulation
returns only marginal reductions of space heating and cooling demands.
© 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Healthcare is provided in complex and energy-intensive facil-
ities that range from critical care hospitals to medical office
buildings. In general, they account for a remarkable fraction of the
energy consumption in the utility buildings sector, due in large part
to the very high energy intensity levels of hospitals and other
inpatient care facilities. Particularly in hospitals, high energy con-
sumptions are mostly due to their continuous usage patterns and
operation which require substantially variable energy demands
depending on the specialized services provided [1]. In addition,
sophisticated heating, ventilation, and air conditioning systems are
necessary to guarantee a careful control of hospitals internal
climate. At the same time, high infiltrations and air changes are
demanded by strict indoor air quality levels required by surgeries,
intensive care units, white rooms, outpatient clinics, etc. [2].
Therefore, in order to guarantee and maintain satisfactory thermal
comfort and indoor air quality levels, continuous demands of
heating and cooling energy, as well as electricity (for artificial
lighting and electrical equipment), yield remarkable energy con-
sumptions, which are relatively higher in comparison with other
types of buildings [3]. Hospital construction techniques also play an
important role on the energy demands. In this regard, existing
hospitals usually consist of large buildings, often known to be
among the least energy efficient public buildings, as it is for most
European countries [3]. As a result, hospital accounts for the
highest energy consumption per unit floor area in the buildings
sector and may offer great potentials for energy and cost savings
through their refurbishment [4]. From this point of view, technical
regulations and directives have been laid down aiming at providing
guidelines and promoting measures for the reduction of the energy
consumption of hospitals [5]. These measures must be adopted and
applied to the hospitals design, construction, retrofit, operations
and maintenance, also by integrating advanced energy efficiency
technologies and renewable energy sources [6e8].
Nevertheless, the reduction of the energy consumptions must
be achieved while preserving or enhancing healthcare delivery.
From this point of view, it must be also noted that depending on the
design conditions of each hospital function, the related technical
system must be properly designed and adjusted in order to meet
* Corresponding author. Tel.: þ39 0817682301; fax: þ39 0812390364.
E-mail address: frcalise@unina.it (F. Calise).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Energy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/energy
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2014.10.042
0360-5442/© 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Energy 78 (2014) 555e572