422 THE JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY
We report a prospective, stratified study of 60 PCA-cups
and 60 RM-polyethylene cups which have been followed
for a median time of 90 months, with annual radiography.
The radiological migration of cups was measured by
the computer-assisted EBRA method. A number of
threshold migration rates from 1 mm in the first year to
1 mm in five years have been assessed and related to
clinically determined revision rates. A total of 28 cups
showed a total migration of 1 mm or more within the
first two years; 13 of these cups have required revision
and been exchanged.
The survival curves of cups which had previously
shown early migration were considerably different from
those without early migration. For cups with a
migration of less than 1 mm within the first two years
the mean survival at 96 months was 0.96 ± 0.02; for
migrating cups, it was 0.63 ± 0.11 (log-rank test, p =
0.0001; chi-square value = 39.4).
Early migration is a good predictor for late loosening
of hip sockets.
J Bone Joint Surg [Br] 1996;78-B:422-6.
Received 31 March 1995; Accepted after revision 21 November 1995
One of the main problems in clinical outcome studies of hip
replacement is that a follow-up of about ten years is
required to obtain reliable information on revision rates. By
the time that results are available the prosthesis may no
longer be in use or may have been modified considerably.
Before such evaluation is complete, many patients may have
been given a prosthesis which has a risk of a poor outcome.
There is a need to predict the results from a new prosthesis
as early as possible.
Freeman and Plante-Bordeneuve (1994) have shown the
predictive value of vertical migration of femoral stems and
several other authors have studied the migration of hip sock-
ets by roentgen stereophotogrammetry (RSA) (Baldursson
et al 1980; Mjöberg et al 1986; Snorrason and Kärrholm
1990; Mjöberg 1991; Onsten et al 1994). These studies sug-
gest that hip sockets which migrate rapidly in the first two
years are more likely to fail than those which do not.
We have investigated the predictive value of socket
migration on survival curves and revision rates.
PATIENTS AND METHODS
Between 4 January 1984 and 10 December 1985 in a pro-
spective, randomised trial we implanted 120 hip prostheses
in patients aged between 50 and 65 years with primary or
secondary osteoarthritis, excluding cases of rheumatoid
arthritis and osteonecrosis. They were stratified with regard
to surgeon and implant, so that two experienced surgeons
performed 60 operations, each implanting 30 Robert Mathys
(RM) cups and 30 Porous-Coated Anatomic (PCA) cups
according to a random-number protocol. The uncemented
all-polyethylene RM cups (Morscher type; Robert Mathys
Co, Bettlach, Switzerland) were combined with ME Müller
straight stems (Protek AG, Berne, Switzerland) and the PCA
cups with PCA stems (Howmedica, Rutherford, New Jersey).
The hip arthroplasties were performed in an ultraclean
laminar-flow operating room. All 60 PCA prostheses were
implanted unilaterally in different patients. One patient had
bilateral RM cups, and this group therefore included 59
patients. For this report we studied only the cups, and all
data refer to these.
The patients had annual follow-up examinations includ-
ing hip radiography and completion of a questionnaire
which since 1991 has used the Standard System of Termi-
nology for Reporting Results (Johnston et al 1990). The
median follow-up time is now 97 months (interquartile
range 78 to 110). In this period 14 patients have died and 20
have had a revision operation for aseptic loosening of the
cup. Excluding these 34 cups, the median follow-up is 104
months (interquartile range 91 to 112). For 60 of these cups
EARLY MIGRATION PREDICTS LATE ASEPTIC
FAILURE OF HIP SOCKETS
M. KRISMER, B. STÖCKL, M. FISCHER, R. BAUER, P. MAYRHOFER,
M. OGON
From the University Orthopaedic Hospital, Innsbruck, Austria
M. Krismer, MD, Senior Registrar
B. Stöckl, MD, Registrar
M. Fischer, MD, Registrar
R. Bauer, MD, Professor of Orthopaedics
M. Ogon, MD, Senior Registrar
University of Innsbruck, Anichstrasse 35, A-6020 Innsbruck, Austria.
P. Mayrhofer, PhD, Assistant Professor
Department of Geometry, Institute of Mathematics and Geometry, Univer-
sity of Innsbruck, Technikerstrasse 13, A-6020 Innsbruck, Austria.
Correspondence should be sent to Dr M. Krismer at the Orthopädische Uni-
versitätsklinik, Anichstrasse 35, A-6020 Innsbruck, Austria.
©1996 British Editorial Society of Bone and Joint Surgery
0301-620X/96/31168 $2.00